Supplementary Material for: Probability of Major Depression Classification Based on the SCID, CIDI, and MINI Diagnostic Interviews: A Synthesis of Three Individual Participant Data Meta-Analyses

  • Lena Spangenberg (Contributor)
  • Dean McMillan (Contributor)
  • Jennie L. Ponsford (Contributor)
  • Emma Robertson-Blackmore (Contributor)
  • Juwita Shaaban (Contributor)
  • Scott B Patten (Contributor)
  • Rocio Martin-Santos (Contributor)
  • Iva Tendais (Contributor)
  • Nathalie Jetté (Contributor)
  • Daniel Okitundu Luwa E-Andjafono (Contributor)
  • Dagmar Amtmann (Contributor)
  • Wenzheng Wang (Contributor)
  • Alastair J. Flint (Contributor)
  • Juliana C.N. Chan (Contributor)
  • Kuan Pin Su (Contributor)
  • Yeates Conwell (Contributor)
  • Rushina Cholera (Contributor)
  • Inger Sundström-Poromaa (Contributor)
  • S. Darius Tandon (Contributor)
  • Sung Wan Kim (Contributor)
  • Pavaani Thiagayson (Contributor)
  • Kylee Trevillion (Contributor)
  • Fl?via L. Os?rio (Contributor)
  • Silje E. Reme (Contributor)
  • Monika Keller (Contributor)
  • Yin Wu (Contributor)
  • Marina G. Downing (Contributor)
  • Laura Navarrete (Contributor)
  • Brian J. Hall (Contributor)
  • C.M. Van Der Feltz-Cornelis (Contributor)
  • Pim Cuijpers (Contributor)
  • Chih Ken Chen (Contributor)
  • Nazanin Saadat (Contributor)
  • Sally Field (Contributor)
  • Eric P. Green (Contributor)
  • Marcello Tonelli (Contributor)
  • Angeliki A. Leonardou (Contributor)
  • Marleine Azar (Contributor)
  • Johann M. Vega-Dienstmaier (Contributor)
  • Felicity Goodyear-Smith (Contributor)
  • Hamid R. Baradaran (Contributor)
  • Stephanie L. Pugh (Contributor)
  • Jill Boruff (Contributor)
  • Anja Mehner (Contributor)
  • Mitsuhiko Yamada (Contributor)
  • Eileen H. Shinn (Contributor)
  • Maria Asuncion Lara (Contributor)
  • Yuying Zhang (Contributor)
  • Bernd Lowe (Contributor)
  • Nicholas Mitchell (Contributor)
  • Katrin Reuter (Contributor)
  • Loreto Massardo (Contributor)
  • Aaron Conway (Contributor)
  • Samir Al-Adawi (Contributor)
  • Lynne I. Wagner (Contributor)
  • Lesley Stafford (Contributor)
  • Emily C. Garman (Contributor)
  • Eli Dabscheck (Contributor)
  • Roy C Ziegelstein (Contributor)
  • Crisanto Diez-Quevedo (Contributor)
  • Roberto Sánchez-González (Contributor)
  • Louise M. Howard (Contributor)
  • Arvin Bhana (Contributor)
  • Rub?n Alvarado (Contributor)
  • Maiko Fujimori (Contributor)
  • Jesse R Fann (Contributor)
  • Anthony Feinstein (Contributor)
  • Marie Hudson (Contributor)
  • Sébastien Simard (Contributor)
  • H.C.P.M. Van Weert (Contributor)
  • Kumiko Muramatsu (Contributor)
  • Carola Bindt (Contributor)
  • Ron?n M. Conroy (Contributor)
  • Dana K. Wong (Contributor)
  • Lisa Giardinelli (Contributor)
  • Bizu Gelaye (Contributor)
  • Paul A. Vöhringer (Contributor)
  • Sharon Sung (Contributor)
  • Barbara Figueiredo (Contributor)
  • Luis Pintor (Contributor)
  • Lorie A Kloda (Contributor)
  • Purificación Navarro García (Contributor)
  • Milena Gandy (Contributor)
  • Felipe Pinheiro de Figueiredo (Contributor)
  • Kira E. Riehm (Contributor)
  • Zoltán Kozinszky (Contributor)
  • Thandi Van Heyningen (Contributor)
  • Nadine Helle (Contributor)
  • Heather J. Rowe (Contributor)
  • Manote Lotrakul (Contributor)
  • Charles H Bombardier (Contributor)
  • Alyna Turner (Contributor)
  • Alkistis Skalkidou (Contributor)
  • B. Arroll (Contributor)
  • S. Singer (Contributor)
  • Thach D. Tran (Contributor)
  • Ying Sun (Contributor)
  • Brett D Thombs (Contributor)
  • Marcos H. Chagas (Contributor)
  • Yutaka Matsuoka (Contributor)
  • Parash Mani Bhandari (Contributor)
  • Antonio L. Teixeira (Contributor)
  • Laurent Misery (Contributor)
  • Jane R.W. Fisher (Contributor)
  • Kimberly A. Yonkers (Contributor)
  • Jacqueline Barnes (Contributor)
  • Pei Lin Lynnette Tan (Contributor)
  • Sultan H. Alamri (Contributor)
  • Zelalem Negeri (Contributor)
  • Dickens H. Akena (Contributor)
  • Robert C. Stewart (Contributor)
  • U. Hegerl (Contributor)
  • Stevan E. Hobfoll (Contributor)
  • Crick Lund (Contributor)
  • John P A Ioannidis (Contributor)
  • Marcelo L. Schwarzbold (Contributor)
  • Cheryl Tatano Beck (Contributor)
  • Pamela Gallagher (Contributor)
  • Valentina Meuti (Contributor)
  • Carmen G. Loiselle (Contributor)
  • Ioannis Michopoulos (Contributor)
  • Leanne Hides (Contributor)
  • Tiago N. Munhoz (Contributor)
  • Luigi Grassi (Contributor)
  • Panagiotis P. Ferentinos (Contributor)
  • Liang Jen Wang (Contributor)
  • Ahmet Öztürk (Contributor)
  • Brandon A. Kohrt (Contributor)
  • Xin Wei Yan (Contributor)
  • Amar D. Bavle (Contributor)
  • Liisa Hantsoo (Contributor)
  • Katherine Turner (Contributor)
  • Kerrie Clover (Contributor)
  • Sandra Nakić Radoš (Contributor)
  • Simone N. Vigod (Contributor)
  • Elles Douven (Contributor)
  • Philip M. Boyce (Contributor)
  • Linda H. Chaudron (Contributor)
  • Alexander W Levis (Contributor)
  • Anna Torres-Giménez (Contributor)
  • Meaghan O'Donnell (Contributor)
  • Istvan Tiringer (Contributor)
  • Alasdair G. Rooney (Contributor)
  • Abbey Sidebottom (Contributor)
  • Angelo Picardi (Contributor)
  • Ian Shrier (Contributor)
  • Qing Zhi Zeng (Contributor)
  • Sebastian Kohler (Contributor)
  • Thomas Hyphantis (Contributor)
  • Martin Härter (Contributor)
  • Femke Lamers (Amsterdam Public Health Research Institute) (Contributor)
  • Robertas Bunevicius (Contributor)
  • Annamária Töreki (Contributor)
  • Tatiana A. Sanchez (Contributor)
  • Liat Ayalon (Contributor)
  • Nagendra P. Luitel (Contributor)
  • Adomas Bunevicius (Contributor)
  • Cosme Alvarado-Esquivel (Contributor)
  • Terence J. Quinn (Contributor)
  • Michelle Fernandes (Contributor)
  • Brian P. Marx (Contributor)
  • Catherine G. Greeno (Contributor)
  • Kim M. Kiely (Contributor)
  • Janneke M. de Man-van Ginkel (Contributor)
  • Melissa Henry (Contributor)
  • Muideen O. Bakare (Contributor)
  • S. Gilbody (Contributor)
  • Anna Beraldi (Contributor)
  • Lorenzo Lelli (Contributor)
  • Danielle B. Rice (Contributor)
  • Daniel Cukor (Contributor)
  • Sonia R Loureiro (Contributor)
  • Daisuke Nishi (Contributor)
  • Tiago Castro e Couto (Contributor)
  • Lluïsa Garcia-Esteve (Contributor)
  • Leila Gholizadeh (Contributor)
  • Holly F. Levin-Aspenson (Contributor)
  • Michael Maes (Contributor)
  • Marie Kjargaard (Contributor)
  • Humberto Correa (Contributor)
  • Valsamma Eapen (Contributor)
  • Mahrukh Imran (Contributor)
  • Sherina Mohd Sidik (Contributor)
  • Ryna Imma Buji (Contributor)
  • Ka Yee Tung (Contributor)
  • Ricard Navines (Contributor)
  • Bonnie W.M. Siu (Contributor)
  • Felix H. Fischer (Contributor)
  • Peter Butterworth (Contributor)
  • L. Sharpe (Contributor)
  • Vesile Senturk Cankorur (Contributor)
  • Daniel S. S. Fung (Contributor)
  • Yunxin Kwan (Contributor)
  • Lai Fong Chan (Contributor)
  • Dina Sami Khalifa (Contributor)
  • Tamsen J. Rochat (Contributor)
  • Brooke Levis (Contributor)
  • Jane Kohlhoff (Contributor)
  • Elmars Rancans (Contributor)
  • Andrea Benedetti (Contributor)
  • Ruth Ann Marrie (Contributor)
  • Mohammad E. Khamseh (Contributor)
  • A. Stein (Contributor)
  • Brian W. Pence (Contributor)
  • M.T. Schram (Contributor)
  • Jian Li Wang (Contributor)
  • Dipika Neupane (Contributor)
  • Gregory Carter (Contributor)
  • Chen He (Contributor)
  • I.S. Santos (Contributor)
  • Simone Honikman (Contributor)
  • Sujit D. Rathod (Contributor)
  • Keiko Suzuki (Contributor)
  • Josef Jenewein (Contributor)
  • Jon Stone (Contributor)
  • Mark Walterfang (Contributor)
  • Karen Wynter (Contributor)
  • Federico M. Daray (Contributor)
  • Matthew J. Chiovitti (Contributor)
  • Jurate Peceliuniene (Contributor)
  • Laura Marsh (Contributor)
  • Juliet E. M. Nakku (Contributor)
  • Charles N. Bernstein (Contributor)
  • Emily E. Haroz (Contributor)
  • Philippe Persoons (Contributor)
  • Serge Sultan (Contributor)
  • Jennifer White (Contributor)
  • Adam Simning (Contributor)
  • M. Tadinac (Contributor)
  • Ankur Krishnan (Contributor)
  • Liane Comeau (Contributor)
  • Masatoshi Inagaki (Contributor)
  • Hong Jin Jeon (Contributor)
  • Natalie Büel-Drabe (Contributor)
  • Laima Kusminskas (Contributor)
  • Lorna J. Gibson (Contributor)
  • Martin Taylor-Rowan (Contributor)
  • Zahinoor Ismail (Contributor)
  • Jurate Butnoriene (Contributor)

Dataset

Description

Introduction: Three previous individual participant data meta-analyses (IPDMAs) reported that, compared to the Structured Clinical Interview for the DSM (SCID), alternative reference standards, primarily the Composite International Diagnostic Interview (CIDI) and the Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview (MINI), tended to misclassify major depression status, when controlling for depression symptom severity. However, there was an important lack of precision in the results. Objective: To compare the odds of the major depression classification based on the SCID, CIDI, and MINI. Methods: We included and standardized data from 3 IPDMA databases. For each IPDMA, separately, we fitted binomial generalized linear mixed models to compare the adjusted odds ratios (aORs) of major depression classification, controlling for symptom severity and characteristics of participants, and the interaction between interview and symptom severity. Next, we synthesized results using a DerSimonian-Laird random-effects meta-analysis. Results: In total, 69,405 participants (7,574 [11%] with major depression) from 212 studies were included. Controlling for symptom severity and participant characteristics, the MINI (74 studies; 25,749 participants) classified major depression more often than the SCID (108 studies; 21,953 participants; aOR 1.46; 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.11–1.92]). Classification odds for the CIDI (30 studies; 21,703 participants) and the SCID did not differ overall (aOR 1.19; 95% CI 0.79–1.75); however, as screening scores increased, the aOR increased less for the CIDI than the SCID (interaction aOR 0.64; 95% CI 0.52–0.80). Conclusions: Compared to the SCID, the MINI classified major depression more often. The odds of the depression classification with the CIDI increased less as symptom levels increased. Interpretation of research that uses diagnostic interviews to classify depression should consider the interview characteristics.
Date made available1 Jan 2020
Publisherfigshare Academic Research System

Cite this