A cross-scale impact assessment of European nature protection policies under contrasting future socio-economic pathways

Hermann Lotze-Campen, Peter H. Verburg, Alexander Popp, Marcus Lindner, Pieter Johannes Verkerk, Alexander Moiseyev, Bep Schrammeijer, John Helming, Andrzej Tabeau, Catharina J.E. Schulp, Emma H. van der Zanden, Carlo Lavalle, Filipe Batista E Silva, Ariane Walz, Benjamin Bodirsky

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

Protection of natural or semi-natural ecosystems is an important part of societal strategies for maintaining biodiversity, ecosystem services, and achieving overall sustainable development. The assessment of multiple emerging land use trade-offs is complicated by the fact that land use changes occur and have consequences at local, regional, and even global scale. Outcomes also depend on the underlying socio-economic trends. We apply a coupled, multi-scale modelling system to assess an increase in nature protection areas as a key policy option in the European Union (EU). The main goal of the analysis is to understand the interactions between policy-induced land use changes across different scales and sectors under two contrasting future socio-economic pathways. We demonstrate how complementary insights into land system change can be gained by coupling land use models for agriculture, forestry, and urban areas for Europe, in connection with other world regions. The simulated policy case of nature protection shows how the allocation of a certain share of total available land to newly protected areas, with specific management restrictions imposed, may have a range of impacts on different land-based sectors until the year 2040. Agricultural land in Europe is slightly reduced, which is partly compensated for by higher management intensity. As a consequence of higher costs, total calorie supply per capita is reduced within the EU. While wood harvest is projected to decrease, carbon sequestration rates increase in European forests. At the same time, imports of industrial roundwood from other world regions are expected to increase. Some of the aggregate effects of nature protection have very different implications at the local to regional scale in different parts of Europe. Due to nature protection measures, agricultural production is shifted from more productive land in Europe to on average less productive land in other parts of the world. This increases, at the global level, the allocation of land resources for agriculture, leading to a decrease in tropical forest areas, reduced carbon stocks, and higher greenhouse gas emissions outside of Europe. The integrated modelling framework provides a method to assess the land use effects of a single policy option while accounting for the trade-offs between locations, and between regional, European, and global scales.

LanguageEnglish
Pages1-12
Number of pages12
JournalRegional Environmental Change
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 16 May 2017

Fingerprint

land use
land use change
European Union
agriculture
ecosystem service
agricultural production
carbon sequestration
tropical forest
modeling
import
socioeconomics
nature protection
land
impact assessment
policy
protected area
forestry
sustainable development
greenhouse gas
agricultural land

Keywords

  • Cross-scale interaction
  • Impact assessment
  • Integrated modelling
  • Land use change
  • Nature protection

Cite this

Lotze-Campen, Hermann ; Verburg, Peter H. ; Popp, Alexander ; Lindner, Marcus ; Verkerk, Pieter Johannes ; Moiseyev, Alexander ; Schrammeijer, Bep ; Helming, John ; Tabeau, Andrzej ; Schulp, Catharina J.E. ; van der Zanden, Emma H. ; Lavalle, Carlo ; E Silva, Filipe Batista ; Walz, Ariane ; Bodirsky, Benjamin. / A cross-scale impact assessment of European nature protection policies under contrasting future socio-economic pathways. In: Regional Environmental Change. 2017 ; pp. 1-12.
@article{da9a743a510343e193795191e2a92bc7,
title = "A cross-scale impact assessment of European nature protection policies under contrasting future socio-economic pathways",
abstract = "Protection of natural or semi-natural ecosystems is an important part of societal strategies for maintaining biodiversity, ecosystem services, and achieving overall sustainable development. The assessment of multiple emerging land use trade-offs is complicated by the fact that land use changes occur and have consequences at local, regional, and even global scale. Outcomes also depend on the underlying socio-economic trends. We apply a coupled, multi-scale modelling system to assess an increase in nature protection areas as a key policy option in the European Union (EU). The main goal of the analysis is to understand the interactions between policy-induced land use changes across different scales and sectors under two contrasting future socio-economic pathways. We demonstrate how complementary insights into land system change can be gained by coupling land use models for agriculture, forestry, and urban areas for Europe, in connection with other world regions. The simulated policy case of nature protection shows how the allocation of a certain share of total available land to newly protected areas, with specific management restrictions imposed, may have a range of impacts on different land-based sectors until the year 2040. Agricultural land in Europe is slightly reduced, which is partly compensated for by higher management intensity. As a consequence of higher costs, total calorie supply per capita is reduced within the EU. While wood harvest is projected to decrease, carbon sequestration rates increase in European forests. At the same time, imports of industrial roundwood from other world regions are expected to increase. Some of the aggregate effects of nature protection have very different implications at the local to regional scale in different parts of Europe. Due to nature protection measures, agricultural production is shifted from more productive land in Europe to on average less productive land in other parts of the world. This increases, at the global level, the allocation of land resources for agriculture, leading to a decrease in tropical forest areas, reduced carbon stocks, and higher greenhouse gas emissions outside of Europe. The integrated modelling framework provides a method to assess the land use effects of a single policy option while accounting for the trade-offs between locations, and between regional, European, and global scales.",
keywords = "Cross-scale interaction, Impact assessment, Integrated modelling, Land use change, Nature protection",
author = "Hermann Lotze-Campen and Verburg, {Peter H.} and Alexander Popp and Marcus Lindner and Verkerk, {Pieter Johannes} and Alexander Moiseyev and Bep Schrammeijer and John Helming and Andrzej Tabeau and Schulp, {Catharina J.E.} and {van der Zanden}, {Emma H.} and Carlo Lavalle and {E Silva}, {Filipe Batista} and Ariane Walz and Benjamin Bodirsky",
year = "2017",
month = "5",
day = "16",
doi = "10.1007/s10113-017-1167-8",
language = "English",
pages = "1--12",
journal = "Regional Environmental Change",
issn = "1436-3798",
publisher = "Springer",

}

Lotze-Campen, H, Verburg, PH, Popp, A, Lindner, M, Verkerk, PJ, Moiseyev, A, Schrammeijer, B, Helming, J, Tabeau, A, Schulp, CJE, van der Zanden, EH, Lavalle, C, E Silva, FB, Walz, A & Bodirsky, B 2017, 'A cross-scale impact assessment of European nature protection policies under contrasting future socio-economic pathways', Regional Environmental Change, pp. 1-12. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-017-1167-8

A cross-scale impact assessment of European nature protection policies under contrasting future socio-economic pathways. / Lotze-Campen, Hermann; Verburg, Peter H.; Popp, Alexander; Lindner, Marcus; Verkerk, Pieter Johannes; Moiseyev, Alexander; Schrammeijer, Bep; Helming, John; Tabeau, Andrzej; Schulp, Catharina J.E.; van der Zanden, Emma H.; Lavalle, Carlo; E Silva, Filipe Batista; Walz, Ariane; Bodirsky, Benjamin.

In: Regional Environmental Change, 16.05.2017, p. 1-12.

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - A cross-scale impact assessment of European nature protection policies under contrasting future socio-economic pathways

AU - Lotze-Campen, Hermann

AU - Verburg, Peter H.

AU - Popp, Alexander

AU - Lindner, Marcus

AU - Verkerk, Pieter Johannes

AU - Moiseyev, Alexander

AU - Schrammeijer, Bep

AU - Helming, John

AU - Tabeau, Andrzej

AU - Schulp, Catharina J.E.

AU - van der Zanden, Emma H.

AU - Lavalle, Carlo

AU - E Silva, Filipe Batista

AU - Walz, Ariane

AU - Bodirsky, Benjamin

PY - 2017/5/16

Y1 - 2017/5/16

N2 - Protection of natural or semi-natural ecosystems is an important part of societal strategies for maintaining biodiversity, ecosystem services, and achieving overall sustainable development. The assessment of multiple emerging land use trade-offs is complicated by the fact that land use changes occur and have consequences at local, regional, and even global scale. Outcomes also depend on the underlying socio-economic trends. We apply a coupled, multi-scale modelling system to assess an increase in nature protection areas as a key policy option in the European Union (EU). The main goal of the analysis is to understand the interactions between policy-induced land use changes across different scales and sectors under two contrasting future socio-economic pathways. We demonstrate how complementary insights into land system change can be gained by coupling land use models for agriculture, forestry, and urban areas for Europe, in connection with other world regions. The simulated policy case of nature protection shows how the allocation of a certain share of total available land to newly protected areas, with specific management restrictions imposed, may have a range of impacts on different land-based sectors until the year 2040. Agricultural land in Europe is slightly reduced, which is partly compensated for by higher management intensity. As a consequence of higher costs, total calorie supply per capita is reduced within the EU. While wood harvest is projected to decrease, carbon sequestration rates increase in European forests. At the same time, imports of industrial roundwood from other world regions are expected to increase. Some of the aggregate effects of nature protection have very different implications at the local to regional scale in different parts of Europe. Due to nature protection measures, agricultural production is shifted from more productive land in Europe to on average less productive land in other parts of the world. This increases, at the global level, the allocation of land resources for agriculture, leading to a decrease in tropical forest areas, reduced carbon stocks, and higher greenhouse gas emissions outside of Europe. The integrated modelling framework provides a method to assess the land use effects of a single policy option while accounting for the trade-offs between locations, and between regional, European, and global scales.

AB - Protection of natural or semi-natural ecosystems is an important part of societal strategies for maintaining biodiversity, ecosystem services, and achieving overall sustainable development. The assessment of multiple emerging land use trade-offs is complicated by the fact that land use changes occur and have consequences at local, regional, and even global scale. Outcomes also depend on the underlying socio-economic trends. We apply a coupled, multi-scale modelling system to assess an increase in nature protection areas as a key policy option in the European Union (EU). The main goal of the analysis is to understand the interactions between policy-induced land use changes across different scales and sectors under two contrasting future socio-economic pathways. We demonstrate how complementary insights into land system change can be gained by coupling land use models for agriculture, forestry, and urban areas for Europe, in connection with other world regions. The simulated policy case of nature protection shows how the allocation of a certain share of total available land to newly protected areas, with specific management restrictions imposed, may have a range of impacts on different land-based sectors until the year 2040. Agricultural land in Europe is slightly reduced, which is partly compensated for by higher management intensity. As a consequence of higher costs, total calorie supply per capita is reduced within the EU. While wood harvest is projected to decrease, carbon sequestration rates increase in European forests. At the same time, imports of industrial roundwood from other world regions are expected to increase. Some of the aggregate effects of nature protection have very different implications at the local to regional scale in different parts of Europe. Due to nature protection measures, agricultural production is shifted from more productive land in Europe to on average less productive land in other parts of the world. This increases, at the global level, the allocation of land resources for agriculture, leading to a decrease in tropical forest areas, reduced carbon stocks, and higher greenhouse gas emissions outside of Europe. The integrated modelling framework provides a method to assess the land use effects of a single policy option while accounting for the trade-offs between locations, and between regional, European, and global scales.

KW - Cross-scale interaction

KW - Impact assessment

KW - Integrated modelling

KW - Land use change

KW - Nature protection

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85019270130&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85019270130&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s10113-017-1167-8

DO - 10.1007/s10113-017-1167-8

M3 - Article

SP - 1

EP - 12

JO - Regional Environmental Change

T2 - Regional Environmental Change

JF - Regional Environmental Change

SN - 1436-3798

ER -