A Matching Model for the Backhaul Problem

Erhan Demirel, Jos van Ommeren, Piet Rietveld

Research output: Working paperProfessional

Abstract

The 'backhaul problem' is characterized by an imbalance in transport flows between locations. This problem is usually studied in a perfectly competitive framework, which essentially predicts that when the imbalance is sufficiently large, the freight price of transport from low demand regions to high demand regions, the so-called backhaul price, drops to zero. This result is inconsistent with empirical observations. In this paper, we develop a matching model to address this inconsistency. We argue that market friction, through search imperfections due to lack of information by carriers on the (future) demand for transport by customers, may play an important role in the determination of backhaul prices. We demonstrate that carriers are at least compensated for the time they search for customers, so the backhaul price is in general positive. The matching model is numerically applied to the inland navigation shipping market in the Rhine river area in Western-Europe. We also analyse the effects of increases in transport costs on transport flows and backhaul prices, e.g. due to climate changes.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationAmsterdam
PublisherTinbergen Instituut
Publication statusPublished - 2007

Publication series

NameDiscussion paper TI
No.07-083/3

Fingerprint

Matching model
Imbalance
Transport costs
Shipping
Climate change
Market frictions
Freight
Imperfections
Inconsistency
Navigation

Cite this

Demirel, E., Ommeren, J. V., & Rietveld, P. (2007). A Matching Model for the Backhaul Problem. (Discussion paper TI; No. 07-083/3). Amsterdam: Tinbergen Instituut.
Demirel, Erhan ; Ommeren, Jos van ; Rietveld, Piet. / A Matching Model for the Backhaul Problem. Amsterdam : Tinbergen Instituut, 2007. (Discussion paper TI; 07-083/3).
@techreport{72094f1614564cf1b9115246c8871122,
title = "A Matching Model for the Backhaul Problem",
abstract = "The 'backhaul problem' is characterized by an imbalance in transport flows between locations. This problem is usually studied in a perfectly competitive framework, which essentially predicts that when the imbalance is sufficiently large, the freight price of transport from low demand regions to high demand regions, the so-called backhaul price, drops to zero. This result is inconsistent with empirical observations. In this paper, we develop a matching model to address this inconsistency. We argue that market friction, through search imperfections due to lack of information by carriers on the (future) demand for transport by customers, may play an important role in the determination of backhaul prices. We demonstrate that carriers are at least compensated for the time they search for customers, so the backhaul price is in general positive. The matching model is numerically applied to the inland navigation shipping market in the Rhine river area in Western-Europe. We also analyse the effects of increases in transport costs on transport flows and backhaul prices, e.g. due to climate changes.",
author = "Erhan Demirel and Ommeren, {Jos van} and Piet Rietveld",
year = "2007",
language = "English",
series = "Discussion paper TI",
publisher = "Tinbergen Instituut",
number = "07-083/3",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "Tinbergen Instituut",

}

Demirel, E, Ommeren, JV & Rietveld, P 2007 'A Matching Model for the Backhaul Problem' Discussion paper TI, no. 07-083/3, Tinbergen Instituut, Amsterdam.

A Matching Model for the Backhaul Problem. / Demirel, Erhan; Ommeren, Jos van; Rietveld, Piet.

Amsterdam : Tinbergen Instituut, 2007. (Discussion paper TI; No. 07-083/3).

Research output: Working paperProfessional

TY - UNPB

T1 - A Matching Model for the Backhaul Problem

AU - Demirel, Erhan

AU - Ommeren, Jos van

AU - Rietveld, Piet

PY - 2007

Y1 - 2007

N2 - The 'backhaul problem' is characterized by an imbalance in transport flows between locations. This problem is usually studied in a perfectly competitive framework, which essentially predicts that when the imbalance is sufficiently large, the freight price of transport from low demand regions to high demand regions, the so-called backhaul price, drops to zero. This result is inconsistent with empirical observations. In this paper, we develop a matching model to address this inconsistency. We argue that market friction, through search imperfections due to lack of information by carriers on the (future) demand for transport by customers, may play an important role in the determination of backhaul prices. We demonstrate that carriers are at least compensated for the time they search for customers, so the backhaul price is in general positive. The matching model is numerically applied to the inland navigation shipping market in the Rhine river area in Western-Europe. We also analyse the effects of increases in transport costs on transport flows and backhaul prices, e.g. due to climate changes.

AB - The 'backhaul problem' is characterized by an imbalance in transport flows between locations. This problem is usually studied in a perfectly competitive framework, which essentially predicts that when the imbalance is sufficiently large, the freight price of transport from low demand regions to high demand regions, the so-called backhaul price, drops to zero. This result is inconsistent with empirical observations. In this paper, we develop a matching model to address this inconsistency. We argue that market friction, through search imperfections due to lack of information by carriers on the (future) demand for transport by customers, may play an important role in the determination of backhaul prices. We demonstrate that carriers are at least compensated for the time they search for customers, so the backhaul price is in general positive. The matching model is numerically applied to the inland navigation shipping market in the Rhine river area in Western-Europe. We also analyse the effects of increases in transport costs on transport flows and backhaul prices, e.g. due to climate changes.

M3 - Working paper

T3 - Discussion paper TI

BT - A Matching Model for the Backhaul Problem

PB - Tinbergen Instituut

CY - Amsterdam

ER -

Demirel E, Ommeren JV, Rietveld P. A Matching Model for the Backhaul Problem. Amsterdam: Tinbergen Instituut. 2007. (Discussion paper TI; 07-083/3).