Accounting for carbon and nitrogen interactions in the global terrestrial ecosystem model ORCHIDEE (trunk version, rev 4999): multi-scale evaluation of gross primary production

Nicolas Vuichard, Palmira Messina, Sebastiaan Luyssaert, Bertrand Guenet, Sönke Zaehle, Josefine Ghattas, Vladislav Bastrikov, Philippe Peylin

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

Nitrogen is an essential element controlling ecosystem carbon (C) productivity and its response to climate change and atmospheric [CO2] increase. This study presents the evaluation -focussing on gross primary production (GPP) -of a new version of the ORCHIDEE model that gathers the representation of the nitrogen cycle and of its interactions with the carbon cycle from the OCN model and the most recent developments from the ORCHIDEE trunk version. We quantify the model skills at 78 FLUXNET sites by simulating the observed mean seasonal cycle, daily mean flux variations, and annual mean average GPP flux for grasslands and forests. Accounting for carbon-nitrogen interactions does not substantially change the main skills of ORCHIDEE, except for the site-to-site annual mean GPP variations, for which the version with carbon-nitrogen interactions is in better agreement with observations. However, the simulated GPP response to idealised [CO2] enrichment simulations is highly sensitive to whether or not carbon-nitrogen interactions are accounted for. Doubling of the atmospheric [CO2] induces an increase in the GPP, but the site-averaged GPP response to a CO2 increase projected by the model version with carbon-nitrogen interactions is half of the increase projected by the version without carbon-nitrogen interactions. This model's differentiated response has important consequences for the transpiration rate, which is on average 50mm yr-1 lower with the version with carbon-nitrogen interactions. Simulated annual GPP for northern, tropical and southern latitudes shows good agreement with the observation-based MTE-GPP (model tree ensemble gross primary production) product for present-day conditions. An attribution experiment making use of this new version of ORCHIDEE for the time period 1860-2016 suggests that global GPP has increased by 50 %, the main driver being the enrichment of land in reactive nitrogen (through deposition and fertilisation), followed by the [CO2] increase. Based on our factorial experiment and sensitivity analysis, we conclude that if carbon-nitrogen interactions are accounted for, the functional responses of ORCHIDEE r4999 better agree with the current understanding of photosynthesis than when the carbon-nitrogen interactions are not accounted for and that carbon-nitrogen interactions are essential in understanding global terrestrial ecosystem productivity.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)4751-4779
Number of pages29
JournalGeoscientific Model Development
Volume12
Issue number11
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 20 Nov 2019

Fingerprint

Gross
Ecosystem
terrestrial ecosystem
Ecosystems
Nitrogen
primary production
Carbon
nitrogen
carbon
Evaluation
Interaction
Model
Annual
Cycle
Productivity
evaluation
Fluxes
productivity
nitrogen cycle
Factorial Experiment

Cite this

Vuichard, Nicolas ; Messina, Palmira ; Luyssaert, Sebastiaan ; Guenet, Bertrand ; Zaehle, Sönke ; Ghattas, Josefine ; Bastrikov, Vladislav ; Peylin, Philippe. / Accounting for carbon and nitrogen interactions in the global terrestrial ecosystem model ORCHIDEE (trunk version, rev 4999) : multi-scale evaluation of gross primary production. In: Geoscientific Model Development. 2019 ; Vol. 12, No. 11. pp. 4751-4779.
@article{aa73a73989b84d7a910206913cc0e32a,
title = "Accounting for carbon and nitrogen interactions in the global terrestrial ecosystem model ORCHIDEE (trunk version, rev 4999): multi-scale evaluation of gross primary production",
abstract = "Nitrogen is an essential element controlling ecosystem carbon (C) productivity and its response to climate change and atmospheric [CO2] increase. This study presents the evaluation -focussing on gross primary production (GPP) -of a new version of the ORCHIDEE model that gathers the representation of the nitrogen cycle and of its interactions with the carbon cycle from the OCN model and the most recent developments from the ORCHIDEE trunk version. We quantify the model skills at 78 FLUXNET sites by simulating the observed mean seasonal cycle, daily mean flux variations, and annual mean average GPP flux for grasslands and forests. Accounting for carbon-nitrogen interactions does not substantially change the main skills of ORCHIDEE, except for the site-to-site annual mean GPP variations, for which the version with carbon-nitrogen interactions is in better agreement with observations. However, the simulated GPP response to idealised [CO2] enrichment simulations is highly sensitive to whether or not carbon-nitrogen interactions are accounted for. Doubling of the atmospheric [CO2] induces an increase in the GPP, but the site-averaged GPP response to a CO2 increase projected by the model version with carbon-nitrogen interactions is half of the increase projected by the version without carbon-nitrogen interactions. This model's differentiated response has important consequences for the transpiration rate, which is on average 50mm yr-1 lower with the version with carbon-nitrogen interactions. Simulated annual GPP for northern, tropical and southern latitudes shows good agreement with the observation-based MTE-GPP (model tree ensemble gross primary production) product for present-day conditions. An attribution experiment making use of this new version of ORCHIDEE for the time period 1860-2016 suggests that global GPP has increased by 50 {\%}, the main driver being the enrichment of land in reactive nitrogen (through deposition and fertilisation), followed by the [CO2] increase. Based on our factorial experiment and sensitivity analysis, we conclude that if carbon-nitrogen interactions are accounted for, the functional responses of ORCHIDEE r4999 better agree with the current understanding of photosynthesis than when the carbon-nitrogen interactions are not accounted for and that carbon-nitrogen interactions are essential in understanding global terrestrial ecosystem productivity.",
author = "Nicolas Vuichard and Palmira Messina and Sebastiaan Luyssaert and Bertrand Guenet and S{\"o}nke Zaehle and Josefine Ghattas and Vladislav Bastrikov and Philippe Peylin",
year = "2019",
month = "11",
day = "20",
doi = "10.5194/gmd-12-4751-2019",
language = "English",
volume = "12",
pages = "4751--4779",
journal = "Geoscientific Model Development",
issn = "1991-959X",
publisher = "Copernicus Gesellschaft mbH",
number = "11",

}

Accounting for carbon and nitrogen interactions in the global terrestrial ecosystem model ORCHIDEE (trunk version, rev 4999) : multi-scale evaluation of gross primary production. / Vuichard, Nicolas; Messina, Palmira; Luyssaert, Sebastiaan; Guenet, Bertrand; Zaehle, Sönke; Ghattas, Josefine; Bastrikov, Vladislav; Peylin, Philippe.

In: Geoscientific Model Development, Vol. 12, No. 11, 20.11.2019, p. 4751-4779.

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Accounting for carbon and nitrogen interactions in the global terrestrial ecosystem model ORCHIDEE (trunk version, rev 4999)

T2 - multi-scale evaluation of gross primary production

AU - Vuichard, Nicolas

AU - Messina, Palmira

AU - Luyssaert, Sebastiaan

AU - Guenet, Bertrand

AU - Zaehle, Sönke

AU - Ghattas, Josefine

AU - Bastrikov, Vladislav

AU - Peylin, Philippe

PY - 2019/11/20

Y1 - 2019/11/20

N2 - Nitrogen is an essential element controlling ecosystem carbon (C) productivity and its response to climate change and atmospheric [CO2] increase. This study presents the evaluation -focussing on gross primary production (GPP) -of a new version of the ORCHIDEE model that gathers the representation of the nitrogen cycle and of its interactions with the carbon cycle from the OCN model and the most recent developments from the ORCHIDEE trunk version. We quantify the model skills at 78 FLUXNET sites by simulating the observed mean seasonal cycle, daily mean flux variations, and annual mean average GPP flux for grasslands and forests. Accounting for carbon-nitrogen interactions does not substantially change the main skills of ORCHIDEE, except for the site-to-site annual mean GPP variations, for which the version with carbon-nitrogen interactions is in better agreement with observations. However, the simulated GPP response to idealised [CO2] enrichment simulations is highly sensitive to whether or not carbon-nitrogen interactions are accounted for. Doubling of the atmospheric [CO2] induces an increase in the GPP, but the site-averaged GPP response to a CO2 increase projected by the model version with carbon-nitrogen interactions is half of the increase projected by the version without carbon-nitrogen interactions. This model's differentiated response has important consequences for the transpiration rate, which is on average 50mm yr-1 lower with the version with carbon-nitrogen interactions. Simulated annual GPP for northern, tropical and southern latitudes shows good agreement with the observation-based MTE-GPP (model tree ensemble gross primary production) product for present-day conditions. An attribution experiment making use of this new version of ORCHIDEE for the time period 1860-2016 suggests that global GPP has increased by 50 %, the main driver being the enrichment of land in reactive nitrogen (through deposition and fertilisation), followed by the [CO2] increase. Based on our factorial experiment and sensitivity analysis, we conclude that if carbon-nitrogen interactions are accounted for, the functional responses of ORCHIDEE r4999 better agree with the current understanding of photosynthesis than when the carbon-nitrogen interactions are not accounted for and that carbon-nitrogen interactions are essential in understanding global terrestrial ecosystem productivity.

AB - Nitrogen is an essential element controlling ecosystem carbon (C) productivity and its response to climate change and atmospheric [CO2] increase. This study presents the evaluation -focussing on gross primary production (GPP) -of a new version of the ORCHIDEE model that gathers the representation of the nitrogen cycle and of its interactions with the carbon cycle from the OCN model and the most recent developments from the ORCHIDEE trunk version. We quantify the model skills at 78 FLUXNET sites by simulating the observed mean seasonal cycle, daily mean flux variations, and annual mean average GPP flux for grasslands and forests. Accounting for carbon-nitrogen interactions does not substantially change the main skills of ORCHIDEE, except for the site-to-site annual mean GPP variations, for which the version with carbon-nitrogen interactions is in better agreement with observations. However, the simulated GPP response to idealised [CO2] enrichment simulations is highly sensitive to whether or not carbon-nitrogen interactions are accounted for. Doubling of the atmospheric [CO2] induces an increase in the GPP, but the site-averaged GPP response to a CO2 increase projected by the model version with carbon-nitrogen interactions is half of the increase projected by the version without carbon-nitrogen interactions. This model's differentiated response has important consequences for the transpiration rate, which is on average 50mm yr-1 lower with the version with carbon-nitrogen interactions. Simulated annual GPP for northern, tropical and southern latitudes shows good agreement with the observation-based MTE-GPP (model tree ensemble gross primary production) product for present-day conditions. An attribution experiment making use of this new version of ORCHIDEE for the time period 1860-2016 suggests that global GPP has increased by 50 %, the main driver being the enrichment of land in reactive nitrogen (through deposition and fertilisation), followed by the [CO2] increase. Based on our factorial experiment and sensitivity analysis, we conclude that if carbon-nitrogen interactions are accounted for, the functional responses of ORCHIDEE r4999 better agree with the current understanding of photosynthesis than when the carbon-nitrogen interactions are not accounted for and that carbon-nitrogen interactions are essential in understanding global terrestrial ecosystem productivity.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85075305839&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85075305839&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.5194/gmd-12-4751-2019

DO - 10.5194/gmd-12-4751-2019

M3 - Article

VL - 12

SP - 4751

EP - 4779

JO - Geoscientific Model Development

JF - Geoscientific Model Development

SN - 1991-959X

IS - 11

ER -