Brexit, the NHS and the double-edged sword of populism: Contributor to agonistic democracy or vehicle of ressentiment?

Manuel Hensmans, K. van Bommel

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

In this paper we argue that mature political democracies require an agonistic form of populism in order to function. Agonistic populism counters technocratic apathy and instrumental reductionism and provides democracies with discursive legitimacy for the expression of antagonisms. We draw on the exemplary case of Brexit to show how the long-term suppression of English populism by an all-conquering British imperial discourse, and the hegemony of technocratic solutions in Europe, transformed populism’s potentially virtuous agonistic effects into an often anachronistic, toxic and ill-directed ressentiment against the European Union. We call upon management scholars to focus on how popular ressentiment can be used as a force for good in two ways: (1) by contributing agonistically to an alternative, emotionally founded discourse about England, the European Union and a new popular civilizational project that could bind them; and (2) by inducing the creation of collective moral categories embraced across the elite/non-elite divide in the image of the post-World War II National Health Service.

Original languageEnglish
JournalOrganization
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 2020

Fingerprint

Health
Democracy
Populism
European Union
Discourse
Hegemony
National Health Service
Reductionism
England
Elites
Legitimacy
Second World War

Keywords

  • Agonism
  • Brexit
  • Chantal Mouffe
  • Ernesto Laclau
  • NHS
  • antagonism
  • populism
  • ressentiment

Cite this

@article{d8d72f41f3a1470c9affaa54553dd6a0,
title = "Brexit, the NHS and the double-edged sword of populism: Contributor to agonistic democracy or vehicle of ressentiment?",
abstract = "In this paper we argue that mature political democracies require an agonistic form of populism in order to function. Agonistic populism counters technocratic apathy and instrumental reductionism and provides democracies with discursive legitimacy for the expression of antagonisms. We draw on the exemplary case of Brexit to show how the long-term suppression of English populism by an all-conquering British imperial discourse, and the hegemony of technocratic solutions in Europe, transformed populism’s potentially virtuous agonistic effects into an often anachronistic, toxic and ill-directed ressentiment against the European Union. We call upon management scholars to focus on how popular ressentiment can be used as a force for good in two ways: (1) by contributing agonistically to an alternative, emotionally founded discourse about England, the European Union and a new popular civilizational project that could bind them; and (2) by inducing the creation of collective moral categories embraced across the elite/non-elite divide in the image of the post-World War II National Health Service.",
keywords = "Agonism, Brexit, Chantal Mouffe, Ernesto Laclau, NHS, antagonism, populism, ressentiment",
author = "Manuel Hensmans and {van Bommel}, K.",
year = "2020",
doi = "10.1177/1350508419855699",
language = "English",
journal = "Organization",
issn = "1350-5084",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",

}

Brexit, the NHS and the double-edged sword of populism: Contributor to agonistic democracy or vehicle of ressentiment? / Hensmans, Manuel; van Bommel, K.

In: Organization, 2020.

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Brexit, the NHS and the double-edged sword of populism: Contributor to agonistic democracy or vehicle of ressentiment?

AU - Hensmans, Manuel

AU - van Bommel, K.

PY - 2020

Y1 - 2020

N2 - In this paper we argue that mature political democracies require an agonistic form of populism in order to function. Agonistic populism counters technocratic apathy and instrumental reductionism and provides democracies with discursive legitimacy for the expression of antagonisms. We draw on the exemplary case of Brexit to show how the long-term suppression of English populism by an all-conquering British imperial discourse, and the hegemony of technocratic solutions in Europe, transformed populism’s potentially virtuous agonistic effects into an often anachronistic, toxic and ill-directed ressentiment against the European Union. We call upon management scholars to focus on how popular ressentiment can be used as a force for good in two ways: (1) by contributing agonistically to an alternative, emotionally founded discourse about England, the European Union and a new popular civilizational project that could bind them; and (2) by inducing the creation of collective moral categories embraced across the elite/non-elite divide in the image of the post-World War II National Health Service.

AB - In this paper we argue that mature political democracies require an agonistic form of populism in order to function. Agonistic populism counters technocratic apathy and instrumental reductionism and provides democracies with discursive legitimacy for the expression of antagonisms. We draw on the exemplary case of Brexit to show how the long-term suppression of English populism by an all-conquering British imperial discourse, and the hegemony of technocratic solutions in Europe, transformed populism’s potentially virtuous agonistic effects into an often anachronistic, toxic and ill-directed ressentiment against the European Union. We call upon management scholars to focus on how popular ressentiment can be used as a force for good in two ways: (1) by contributing agonistically to an alternative, emotionally founded discourse about England, the European Union and a new popular civilizational project that could bind them; and (2) by inducing the creation of collective moral categories embraced across the elite/non-elite divide in the image of the post-World War II National Health Service.

KW - Agonism

KW - Brexit

KW - Chantal Mouffe

KW - Ernesto Laclau

KW - NHS

KW - antagonism

KW - populism

KW - ressentiment

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85068228926&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85068228926&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/1350508419855699

DO - 10.1177/1350508419855699

M3 - Article

JO - Organization

JF - Organization

SN - 1350-5084

ER -