Change in metaphorical framing over time: Metaphors of TRADE in 225 years of State of the Union addresses (1790-2014)

C.F. Burgers, Kathleen Ahrens

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

The literature provides diverging perspectives on the universality and stability of economic metaphors over time. This article contains a diachronic analysis of economic metaphors describing trade in a corpus of 225 years of US State of the Union addresses (1790-2014). We focused on two types of change: (1) replacement of a source domain by another domain and (2) change in mapping within a source domain. In our corpus, five source domains of trade were predominant: (a) PHYSICAL OBJECT, (b) BUILDING, (c) CONTAINER, (d) JOURNEY and (e) LIVING BEING. Only the relative frequency of the CONTAINER source domain was related to time. Additionally, mappings between source and target domains were mostly stable. Nevertheless, our analyses suggest that the TRADE metaphors in our corpus are related to concreteness in a more nuanced way as typically assumed in Conceptual Metaphor Theory: Metaphors high in the concreteness dimension of physicality and low in the concreteness dimension of specificity are likeliest to be used over longer time periods, by providing communicators with freedom to adjust the metaphor to changing societal circumstances.
Original languageEnglish
JournalApplied Linguistics
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 2019

Fingerprint

metaphor
Economics
communicator
economics
time
Source Domain
Concreteness

Keywords

  • Metaphor
  • Diachronic analysis
  • Economic discourse
  • Political communication
  • State of the Union

Cite this

@article{3cba5c59e65a4af8b5f49aa29dc4b965,
title = "Change in metaphorical framing over time: Metaphors of TRADE in 225 years of State of the Union addresses (1790-2014)",
abstract = "The literature provides diverging perspectives on the universality and stability of economic metaphors over time. This article contains a diachronic analysis of economic metaphors describing trade in a corpus of 225 years of US State of the Union addresses (1790-2014). We focused on two types of change: (1) replacement of a source domain by another domain and (2) change in mapping within a source domain. In our corpus, five source domains of trade were predominant: (a) PHYSICAL OBJECT, (b) BUILDING, (c) CONTAINER, (d) JOURNEY and (e) LIVING BEING. Only the relative frequency of the CONTAINER source domain was related to time. Additionally, mappings between source and target domains were mostly stable. Nevertheless, our analyses suggest that the TRADE metaphors in our corpus are related to concreteness in a more nuanced way as typically assumed in Conceptual Metaphor Theory: Metaphors high in the concreteness dimension of physicality and low in the concreteness dimension of specificity are likeliest to be used over longer time periods, by providing communicators with freedom to adjust the metaphor to changing societal circumstances.",
keywords = "Metaphor, Diachronic analysis, Economic discourse, Political communication, State of the Union",
author = "C.F. Burgers and Kathleen Ahrens",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.1093/applin/amy055",
language = "English",
journal = "Applied Linguistics",
issn = "0142-6001",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",

}

Change in metaphorical framing over time: Metaphors of TRADE in 225 years of State of the Union addresses (1790-2014). / Burgers, C.F.; Ahrens, Kathleen.

In: Applied Linguistics, 2019.

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Change in metaphorical framing over time: Metaphors of TRADE in 225 years of State of the Union addresses (1790-2014)

AU - Burgers, C.F.

AU - Ahrens, Kathleen

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - The literature provides diverging perspectives on the universality and stability of economic metaphors over time. This article contains a diachronic analysis of economic metaphors describing trade in a corpus of 225 years of US State of the Union addresses (1790-2014). We focused on two types of change: (1) replacement of a source domain by another domain and (2) change in mapping within a source domain. In our corpus, five source domains of trade were predominant: (a) PHYSICAL OBJECT, (b) BUILDING, (c) CONTAINER, (d) JOURNEY and (e) LIVING BEING. Only the relative frequency of the CONTAINER source domain was related to time. Additionally, mappings between source and target domains were mostly stable. Nevertheless, our analyses suggest that the TRADE metaphors in our corpus are related to concreteness in a more nuanced way as typically assumed in Conceptual Metaphor Theory: Metaphors high in the concreteness dimension of physicality and low in the concreteness dimension of specificity are likeliest to be used over longer time periods, by providing communicators with freedom to adjust the metaphor to changing societal circumstances.

AB - The literature provides diverging perspectives on the universality and stability of economic metaphors over time. This article contains a diachronic analysis of economic metaphors describing trade in a corpus of 225 years of US State of the Union addresses (1790-2014). We focused on two types of change: (1) replacement of a source domain by another domain and (2) change in mapping within a source domain. In our corpus, five source domains of trade were predominant: (a) PHYSICAL OBJECT, (b) BUILDING, (c) CONTAINER, (d) JOURNEY and (e) LIVING BEING. Only the relative frequency of the CONTAINER source domain was related to time. Additionally, mappings between source and target domains were mostly stable. Nevertheless, our analyses suggest that the TRADE metaphors in our corpus are related to concreteness in a more nuanced way as typically assumed in Conceptual Metaphor Theory: Metaphors high in the concreteness dimension of physicality and low in the concreteness dimension of specificity are likeliest to be used over longer time periods, by providing communicators with freedom to adjust the metaphor to changing societal circumstances.

KW - Metaphor

KW - Diachronic analysis

KW - Economic discourse

KW - Political communication

KW - State of the Union

U2 - 10.1093/applin/amy055

DO - 10.1093/applin/amy055

M3 - Article

JO - Applied Linguistics

JF - Applied Linguistics

SN - 0142-6001

ER -