Collaborative meta-analysis finds no evidence of a strong interaction between stress and 5-HTTLPR genotype contributing to the development of depression

R C Culverhouse, N.L. Saccone, A C Horton, Y Ma, K J Anstey, T. Banaschewski, M. Burmeister, Sarah Cohen-Woods, B. Etain, H L Fisher, N Goldman, S Guillaume, J. Horwood, G Juhasz, K J Lester, L Mandelli, C M Middeldorp, E Olié, S. Villafuerte, T M Air & 73 others R. Araya, L Bowes, M.R. Burns, Enda M Byrne, J.C. Coffey, W.L. Coventry, K A B Gawronski, D Glei, A Hatzimanolis, J-J Hottenga, I Jaussent, C Jawahar, C Jennen-Steinmetz, J R Kramer, M Lajnef, K Little, H. Meyer zu Schwabedissen, M. Nauck, E. Nederhof, P Petschner, Wouter J Peyrot, C Schwahn, G Sinnamon, D. Stacey, Y Tian, C Toben, Sandra Van der Auwera, N.W. Wainwright, J-C Wang, G Willemsen, I M Anderson, V. Arolt, C Åslund, G Bagdy, Bernard T Baune, F. Bellivier, D I Boomsma, P Courtet, Udo Dannlowski, E J C de Geus, J F W Deakin, S Easteal, T.C. Eley, D.M. Fergusson, A.M. Goate, X Gonda, Hans J Grabe, C Holzman, E.O. Johnson, D.M. Kennedy, M Laucht, Nicholas G Martin, Marcus R Munafò, K.W. Nilsson, Albertine J Oldehinkel, C A Olsson, J. Ormel, C. Otte, G C Patton, B W J H Penninx, K Ritchie, M. Sarchiapone, J M Scheid, A Serretti, J H Smit, N C Stefanis, P G Surtees, H. Völzke, M Weinstein, M.A. Whooley, J.I. Nurnberger, N. Breslau, L.J. Bierut

Research output: Scientific - peer-reviewArticle

Abstract

The hypothesis that the S allele of the 5-HTTLPR serotonin transporter promoter region is associated with increased risk of depression, but only in individuals exposed to stressful situations, has generated much interest, research and controversy since first proposed in 2003. Multiple meta-analyses combining results from heterogeneous analyses have not settled the issue. To determine the magnitude of the interaction and the conditions under which it might be observed, we performed new analyses on 31 data sets containing 38 802 European ancestry subjects genotyped for 5-HTTLPR and assessed for depression and childhood maltreatment or other stressful life events, and meta-analysed the results. Analyses targeted two stressors (narrow, broad) and two depression outcomes (current, lifetime). All groups that published on this topic prior to the initiation of our study and met the assessment and sample size criteria were invited to participate. Additional groups, identified by consortium members or self-identified in response to our protocol (published prior to the start of analysis) with qualifying unpublished data, were also invited to participate. A uniform data analysis script implementing the protocol was executed by each of the consortium members. Our findings do not support the interaction hypothesis. We found no subgroups or variable definitions for which an interaction between stress and 5-HTTLPR genotype was statistically significant. In contrast, our findings for the main effects of life stressors (strong risk factor) and 5-HTTLPR genotype (no impact on risk) are strikingly consistent across our contributing studies, the original study reporting the interaction and subsequent meta-analyses. Our conclusion is that if an interaction exists in which the S allele of 5-HTTLPR increases risk of depression only in stressed individuals, then it is not broadly generalisable, but must be of modest effect size and only observable in limited situations.Molecular Psychiatry advance online publication, 4 April 2017; doi:10.1038/mp.2017.44.

LanguageEnglish
Pages133-142
JournalMolecular Psychiatry
Volume23
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - 2 Jan 2018

Cite this

Culverhouse, R. C., Saccone, N. L., Horton, A. C., Ma, Y., Anstey, K. J., Banaschewski, T., ... Bierut, L. J. (2018). Collaborative meta-analysis finds no evidence of a strong interaction between stress and 5-HTTLPR genotype contributing to the development of depression. Molecular Psychiatry, 23(1), 133-142. DOI: 10.1038/mp.2017.44
Culverhouse, R C ; Saccone, N.L. ; Horton, A C ; Ma, Y ; Anstey, K J ; Banaschewski, T. ; Burmeister, M. ; Cohen-Woods, Sarah ; Etain, B. ; Fisher, H L ; Goldman, N ; Guillaume, S ; Horwood, J. ; Juhasz, G ; Lester, K J ; Mandelli, L ; Middeldorp, C M ; Olié, E ; Villafuerte, S. ; Air, T M ; Araya, R. ; Bowes, L ; Burns, M.R. ; Byrne, Enda M ; Coffey, J.C. ; Coventry, W.L. ; Gawronski, K A B ; Glei, D ; Hatzimanolis, A ; Hottenga, J-J ; Jaussent, I ; Jawahar, C ; Jennen-Steinmetz, C ; Kramer, J R ; Lajnef, M ; Little, K ; Meyer zu Schwabedissen, H. ; Nauck, M. ; Nederhof, E. ; Petschner, P ; Peyrot, Wouter J ; Schwahn, C ; Sinnamon, G ; Stacey, D. ; Tian, Y ; Toben, C ; Van der Auwera, Sandra ; Wainwright, N.W. ; Wang, J-C ; Willemsen, G ; Anderson, I M ; Arolt, V. ; Åslund, C ; Bagdy, G ; Baune, Bernard T ; Bellivier, F. ; Boomsma, D I ; Courtet, P ; Dannlowski, Udo ; de Geus, E J C ; Deakin, J F W ; Easteal, S ; Eley, T.C. ; Fergusson, D.M. ; Goate, A.M. ; Gonda, X ; Grabe, Hans J ; Holzman, C ; Johnson, E.O. ; Kennedy, D.M. ; Laucht, M ; Martin, Nicholas G ; Munafò, Marcus R ; Nilsson, K.W. ; Oldehinkel, Albertine J ; Olsson, C A ; Ormel, J. ; Otte, C. ; Patton, G C ; Penninx, B W J H ; Ritchie, K ; Sarchiapone, M. ; Scheid, J M ; Serretti, A ; Smit, J H ; Stefanis, N C ; Surtees, P G ; Völzke, H. ; Weinstein, M ; Whooley, M.A. ; Nurnberger, J.I. ; Breslau, N. ; Bierut, L.J./ Collaborative meta-analysis finds no evidence of a strong interaction between stress and 5-HTTLPR genotype contributing to the development of depression. In: Molecular Psychiatry. 2018 ; Vol. 23, No. 1. pp. 133-142
@article{a867d0adf3ba415d88642e5179ee0216,
title = "Collaborative meta-analysis finds no evidence of a strong interaction between stress and 5-HTTLPR genotype contributing to the development of depression",
abstract = "The hypothesis that the S allele of the 5-HTTLPR serotonin transporter promoter region is associated with increased risk of depression, but only in individuals exposed to stressful situations, has generated much interest, research and controversy since first proposed in 2003. Multiple meta-analyses combining results from heterogeneous analyses have not settled the issue. To determine the magnitude of the interaction and the conditions under which it might be observed, we performed new analyses on 31 data sets containing 38 802 European ancestry subjects genotyped for 5-HTTLPR and assessed for depression and childhood maltreatment or other stressful life events, and meta-analysed the results. Analyses targeted two stressors (narrow, broad) and two depression outcomes (current, lifetime). All groups that published on this topic prior to the initiation of our study and met the assessment and sample size criteria were invited to participate. Additional groups, identified by consortium members or self-identified in response to our protocol (published prior to the start of analysis) with qualifying unpublished data, were also invited to participate. A uniform data analysis script implementing the protocol was executed by each of the consortium members. Our findings do not support the interaction hypothesis. We found no subgroups or variable definitions for which an interaction between stress and 5-HTTLPR genotype was statistically significant. In contrast, our findings for the main effects of life stressors (strong risk factor) and 5-HTTLPR genotype (no impact on risk) are strikingly consistent across our contributing studies, the original study reporting the interaction and subsequent meta-analyses. Our conclusion is that if an interaction exists in which the S allele of 5-HTTLPR increases risk of depression only in stressed individuals, then it is not broadly generalisable, but must be of modest effect size and only observable in limited situations.Molecular Psychiatry advance online publication, 4 April 2017; doi:10.1038/mp.2017.44.",
keywords = "Journal Article",
author = "Culverhouse, {R C} and N.L. Saccone and Horton, {A C} and Y Ma and Anstey, {K J} and T. Banaschewski and M. Burmeister and Sarah Cohen-Woods and B. Etain and Fisher, {H L} and N Goldman and S Guillaume and J. Horwood and G Juhasz and Lester, {K J} and L Mandelli and Middeldorp, {C M} and E Olié and S. Villafuerte and Air, {T M} and R. Araya and L Bowes and M.R. Burns and Byrne, {Enda M} and J.C. Coffey and W.L. Coventry and Gawronski, {K A B} and D Glei and A Hatzimanolis and J-J Hottenga and I Jaussent and C Jawahar and C Jennen-Steinmetz and Kramer, {J R} and M Lajnef and K Little and {Meyer zu Schwabedissen}, H. and M. Nauck and E. Nederhof and P Petschner and Peyrot, {Wouter J} and C Schwahn and G Sinnamon and D. Stacey and Y Tian and C Toben and {Van der Auwera}, Sandra and N.W. Wainwright and J-C Wang and G Willemsen and Anderson, {I M} and V. Arolt and C Åslund and G Bagdy and Baune, {Bernard T} and F. Bellivier and Boomsma, {D I} and P Courtet and Udo Dannlowski and {de Geus}, {E J C} and Deakin, {J F W} and S Easteal and T.C. Eley and D.M. Fergusson and A.M. Goate and X Gonda and Grabe, {Hans J} and C Holzman and E.O. Johnson and D.M. Kennedy and M Laucht and Martin, {Nicholas G} and Munafò, {Marcus R} and K.W. Nilsson and Oldehinkel, {Albertine J} and Olsson, {C A} and J. Ormel and C. Otte and Patton, {G C} and Penninx, {B W J H} and K Ritchie and M. Sarchiapone and Scheid, {J M} and A Serretti and Smit, {J H} and Stefanis, {N C} and Surtees, {P G} and H. Völzke and M Weinstein and M.A. Whooley and J.I. Nurnberger and N. Breslau and L.J. Bierut",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1038/mp.2017.44",
volume = "23",
pages = "133--142",
journal = "Molecular Psychiatry",
issn = "1359-4184",
publisher = "Nature Publishing Group",
number = "1",

}

Culverhouse, RC, Saccone, NL, Horton, AC, Ma, Y, Anstey, KJ, Banaschewski, T, Burmeister, M, Cohen-Woods, S, Etain, B, Fisher, HL, Goldman, N, Guillaume, S, Horwood, J, Juhasz, G, Lester, KJ, Mandelli, L, Middeldorp, CM, Olié, E, Villafuerte, S, Air, TM, Araya, R, Bowes, L, Burns, MR, Byrne, EM, Coffey, JC, Coventry, WL, Gawronski, KAB, Glei, D, Hatzimanolis, A, Hottenga, J-J, Jaussent, I, Jawahar, C, Jennen-Steinmetz, C, Kramer, JR, Lajnef, M, Little, K, Meyer zu Schwabedissen, H, Nauck, M, Nederhof, E, Petschner, P, Peyrot, WJ, Schwahn, C, Sinnamon, G, Stacey, D, Tian, Y, Toben, C, Van der Auwera, S, Wainwright, NW, Wang, J-C, Willemsen, G, Anderson, IM, Arolt, V, Åslund, C, Bagdy, G, Baune, BT, Bellivier, F, Boomsma, DI, Courtet, P, Dannlowski, U, de Geus, EJC, Deakin, JFW, Easteal, S, Eley, TC, Fergusson, DM, Goate, AM, Gonda, X, Grabe, HJ, Holzman, C, Johnson, EO, Kennedy, DM, Laucht, M, Martin, NG, Munafò, MR, Nilsson, KW, Oldehinkel, AJ, Olsson, CA, Ormel, J, Otte, C, Patton, GC, Penninx, BWJH, Ritchie, K, Sarchiapone, M, Scheid, JM, Serretti, A, Smit, JH, Stefanis, NC, Surtees, PG, Völzke, H, Weinstein, M, Whooley, MA, Nurnberger, JI, Breslau, N & Bierut, LJ 2018, 'Collaborative meta-analysis finds no evidence of a strong interaction between stress and 5-HTTLPR genotype contributing to the development of depression' Molecular Psychiatry, vol 23, no. 1, pp. 133-142. DOI: 10.1038/mp.2017.44

Collaborative meta-analysis finds no evidence of a strong interaction between stress and 5-HTTLPR genotype contributing to the development of depression. / Culverhouse, R C; Saccone, N.L.; Horton, A C; Ma, Y; Anstey, K J; Banaschewski, T.; Burmeister, M.; Cohen-Woods, Sarah; Etain, B.; Fisher, H L; Goldman, N; Guillaume, S; Horwood, J.; Juhasz, G; Lester, K J; Mandelli, L; Middeldorp, C M; Olié, E; Villafuerte, S.; Air, T M; Araya, R.; Bowes, L; Burns, M.R.; Byrne, Enda M; Coffey, J.C.; Coventry, W.L.; Gawronski, K A B; Glei, D; Hatzimanolis, A; Hottenga, J-J; Jaussent, I; Jawahar, C; Jennen-Steinmetz, C; Kramer, J R; Lajnef, M; Little, K; Meyer zu Schwabedissen, H.; Nauck, M.; Nederhof, E.; Petschner, P; Peyrot, Wouter J; Schwahn, C; Sinnamon, G; Stacey, D.; Tian, Y; Toben, C; Van der Auwera, Sandra; Wainwright, N.W.; Wang, J-C; Willemsen, G; Anderson, I M; Arolt, V.; Åslund, C; Bagdy, G; Baune, Bernard T; Bellivier, F.; Boomsma, D I; Courtet, P; Dannlowski, Udo; de Geus, E J C; Deakin, J F W; Easteal, S; Eley, T.C.; Fergusson, D.M.; Goate, A.M.; Gonda, X; Grabe, Hans J; Holzman, C; Johnson, E.O.; Kennedy, D.M.; Laucht, M; Martin, Nicholas G; Munafò, Marcus R; Nilsson, K.W.; Oldehinkel, Albertine J; Olsson, C A; Ormel, J.; Otte, C.; Patton, G C; Penninx, B W J H; Ritchie, K; Sarchiapone, M.; Scheid, J M; Serretti, A; Smit, J H; Stefanis, N C; Surtees, P G; Völzke, H.; Weinstein, M; Whooley, M.A.; Nurnberger, J.I.; Breslau, N.; Bierut, L.J.

In: Molecular Psychiatry, Vol. 23, No. 1, 02.01.2018, p. 133-142.

Research output: Scientific - peer-reviewArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Collaborative meta-analysis finds no evidence of a strong interaction between stress and 5-HTTLPR genotype contributing to the development of depression

AU - Culverhouse,R C

AU - Saccone,N.L.

AU - Horton,A C

AU - Ma,Y

AU - Anstey,K J

AU - Banaschewski,T.

AU - Burmeister,M.

AU - Cohen-Woods,Sarah

AU - Etain,B.

AU - Fisher,H L

AU - Goldman,N

AU - Guillaume,S

AU - Horwood,J.

AU - Juhasz,G

AU - Lester,K J

AU - Mandelli,L

AU - Middeldorp,C M

AU - Olié,E

AU - Villafuerte,S.

AU - Air,T M

AU - Araya,R.

AU - Bowes,L

AU - Burns,M.R.

AU - Byrne,Enda M

AU - Coffey,J.C.

AU - Coventry,W.L.

AU - Gawronski,K A B

AU - Glei,D

AU - Hatzimanolis,A

AU - Hottenga,J-J

AU - Jaussent,I

AU - Jawahar,C

AU - Jennen-Steinmetz,C

AU - Kramer,J R

AU - Lajnef,M

AU - Little,K

AU - Meyer zu Schwabedissen,H.

AU - Nauck,M.

AU - Nederhof,E.

AU - Petschner,P

AU - Peyrot,Wouter J

AU - Schwahn,C

AU - Sinnamon,G

AU - Stacey,D.

AU - Tian,Y

AU - Toben,C

AU - Van der Auwera,Sandra

AU - Wainwright,N.W.

AU - Wang,J-C

AU - Willemsen,G

AU - Anderson,I M

AU - Arolt,V.

AU - Åslund,C

AU - Bagdy,G

AU - Baune,Bernard T

AU - Bellivier,F.

AU - Boomsma,D I

AU - Courtet,P

AU - Dannlowski,Udo

AU - de Geus,E J C

AU - Deakin,J F W

AU - Easteal,S

AU - Eley,T.C.

AU - Fergusson,D.M.

AU - Goate,A.M.

AU - Gonda,X

AU - Grabe,Hans J

AU - Holzman,C

AU - Johnson,E.O.

AU - Kennedy,D.M.

AU - Laucht,M

AU - Martin,Nicholas G

AU - Munafò,Marcus R

AU - Nilsson,K.W.

AU - Oldehinkel,Albertine J

AU - Olsson,C A

AU - Ormel,J.

AU - Otte,C.

AU - Patton,G C

AU - Penninx,B W J H

AU - Ritchie,K

AU - Sarchiapone,M.

AU - Scheid,J M

AU - Serretti,A

AU - Smit,J H

AU - Stefanis,N C

AU - Surtees,P G

AU - Völzke,H.

AU - Weinstein,M

AU - Whooley,M.A.

AU - Nurnberger,J.I.

AU - Breslau,N.

AU - Bierut,L.J.

PY - 2018/1/2

Y1 - 2018/1/2

N2 - The hypothesis that the S allele of the 5-HTTLPR serotonin transporter promoter region is associated with increased risk of depression, but only in individuals exposed to stressful situations, has generated much interest, research and controversy since first proposed in 2003. Multiple meta-analyses combining results from heterogeneous analyses have not settled the issue. To determine the magnitude of the interaction and the conditions under which it might be observed, we performed new analyses on 31 data sets containing 38 802 European ancestry subjects genotyped for 5-HTTLPR and assessed for depression and childhood maltreatment or other stressful life events, and meta-analysed the results. Analyses targeted two stressors (narrow, broad) and two depression outcomes (current, lifetime). All groups that published on this topic prior to the initiation of our study and met the assessment and sample size criteria were invited to participate. Additional groups, identified by consortium members or self-identified in response to our protocol (published prior to the start of analysis) with qualifying unpublished data, were also invited to participate. A uniform data analysis script implementing the protocol was executed by each of the consortium members. Our findings do not support the interaction hypothesis. We found no subgroups or variable definitions for which an interaction between stress and 5-HTTLPR genotype was statistically significant. In contrast, our findings for the main effects of life stressors (strong risk factor) and 5-HTTLPR genotype (no impact on risk) are strikingly consistent across our contributing studies, the original study reporting the interaction and subsequent meta-analyses. Our conclusion is that if an interaction exists in which the S allele of 5-HTTLPR increases risk of depression only in stressed individuals, then it is not broadly generalisable, but must be of modest effect size and only observable in limited situations.Molecular Psychiatry advance online publication, 4 April 2017; doi:10.1038/mp.2017.44.

AB - The hypothesis that the S allele of the 5-HTTLPR serotonin transporter promoter region is associated with increased risk of depression, but only in individuals exposed to stressful situations, has generated much interest, research and controversy since first proposed in 2003. Multiple meta-analyses combining results from heterogeneous analyses have not settled the issue. To determine the magnitude of the interaction and the conditions under which it might be observed, we performed new analyses on 31 data sets containing 38 802 European ancestry subjects genotyped for 5-HTTLPR and assessed for depression and childhood maltreatment or other stressful life events, and meta-analysed the results. Analyses targeted two stressors (narrow, broad) and two depression outcomes (current, lifetime). All groups that published on this topic prior to the initiation of our study and met the assessment and sample size criteria were invited to participate. Additional groups, identified by consortium members or self-identified in response to our protocol (published prior to the start of analysis) with qualifying unpublished data, were also invited to participate. A uniform data analysis script implementing the protocol was executed by each of the consortium members. Our findings do not support the interaction hypothesis. We found no subgroups or variable definitions for which an interaction between stress and 5-HTTLPR genotype was statistically significant. In contrast, our findings for the main effects of life stressors (strong risk factor) and 5-HTTLPR genotype (no impact on risk) are strikingly consistent across our contributing studies, the original study reporting the interaction and subsequent meta-analyses. Our conclusion is that if an interaction exists in which the S allele of 5-HTTLPR increases risk of depression only in stressed individuals, then it is not broadly generalisable, but must be of modest effect size and only observable in limited situations.Molecular Psychiatry advance online publication, 4 April 2017; doi:10.1038/mp.2017.44.

KW - Journal Article

U2 - 10.1038/mp.2017.44

DO - 10.1038/mp.2017.44

M3 - Article

VL - 23

SP - 133

EP - 142

JO - Molecular Psychiatry

T2 - Molecular Psychiatry

JF - Molecular Psychiatry

SN - 1359-4184

IS - 1

ER -

Culverhouse RC, Saccone NL, Horton AC, Ma Y, Anstey KJ, Banaschewski T et al. Collaborative meta-analysis finds no evidence of a strong interaction between stress and 5-HTTLPR genotype contributing to the development of depression. Molecular Psychiatry. 2018 Jan 2;23(1):133-142. Available from, DOI: 10.1038/mp.2017.44