Cultural determinants of regulation and supervision of pension funds

J.A. Rivera Rozo, S.G. van der Lecq, O.W. Steenbeek

Research output: Working paperProfessional

Abstract

There is considerable variation in pension systems across countries. Pension funds regulation and supervision are two characteristics of pension systems that exemplify such variation. Pension funds regulation and supervisory activities differ in their degree of intensity and strictness. We investigate to what extent national culture plays a role in explaining differences in approaches to the regulation and supervision of pension funds. As measures of national culture, Hofstede’s cultural dimensions are used. First, we find that countries characterized by higher individualism are strongly related to lower investment restrictions that pension funds are allowed to make. This relationship is found using three different measures of investment restrictions. Second, we find that higher scores on uncertainty avoidance and power distance, and lower scores on individualism are associated with stricter reporting requirements that pension funds have to fulfill. All results are robust to changes in the measures of cultural variables (updated versions of Hofstede’s cultural dimensions) and alternative estimation procedures (Tobit and Instrumental Variables regressions).
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationTilburg
PublisherNetspar
Number of pages34
Publication statusPublished - 2013

Fingerprint

Regulation and supervision
Pension funds
Cultural dimensions
National cultures
Individualism
Pension system
Instrumental variables regression
Uncertainty avoidance
Power distance
Tobit

Cite this

Rivera Rozo, J. A., van der Lecq, S. G., & Steenbeek, O. W. (2013). Cultural determinants of regulation and supervision of pension funds. Tilburg: Netspar.
Rivera Rozo, J.A. ; van der Lecq, S.G. ; Steenbeek, O.W. / Cultural determinants of regulation and supervision of pension funds. Tilburg : Netspar, 2013.
@techreport{41bb2a44247a4a5b9ddde6d694e5e0e9,
title = "Cultural determinants of regulation and supervision of pension funds",
abstract = "There is considerable variation in pension systems across countries. Pension funds regulation and supervision are two characteristics of pension systems that exemplify such variation. Pension funds regulation and supervisory activities differ in their degree of intensity and strictness. We investigate to what extent national culture plays a role in explaining differences in approaches to the regulation and supervision of pension funds. As measures of national culture, Hofstede’s cultural dimensions are used. First, we find that countries characterized by higher individualism are strongly related to lower investment restrictions that pension funds are allowed to make. This relationship is found using three different measures of investment restrictions. Second, we find that higher scores on uncertainty avoidance and power distance, and lower scores on individualism are associated with stricter reporting requirements that pension funds have to fulfill. All results are robust to changes in the measures of cultural variables (updated versions of Hofstede’s cultural dimensions) and alternative estimation procedures (Tobit and Instrumental Variables regressions).",
author = "{Rivera Rozo}, J.A. and {van der Lecq}, S.G. and O.W. Steenbeek",
year = "2013",
language = "English",
publisher = "Netspar",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "Netspar",

}

Cultural determinants of regulation and supervision of pension funds. / Rivera Rozo, J.A.; van der Lecq, S.G.; Steenbeek, O.W.

Tilburg : Netspar, 2013.

Research output: Working paperProfessional

TY - UNPB

T1 - Cultural determinants of regulation and supervision of pension funds

AU - Rivera Rozo, J.A.

AU - van der Lecq, S.G.

AU - Steenbeek, O.W.

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - There is considerable variation in pension systems across countries. Pension funds regulation and supervision are two characteristics of pension systems that exemplify such variation. Pension funds regulation and supervisory activities differ in their degree of intensity and strictness. We investigate to what extent national culture plays a role in explaining differences in approaches to the regulation and supervision of pension funds. As measures of national culture, Hofstede’s cultural dimensions are used. First, we find that countries characterized by higher individualism are strongly related to lower investment restrictions that pension funds are allowed to make. This relationship is found using three different measures of investment restrictions. Second, we find that higher scores on uncertainty avoidance and power distance, and lower scores on individualism are associated with stricter reporting requirements that pension funds have to fulfill. All results are robust to changes in the measures of cultural variables (updated versions of Hofstede’s cultural dimensions) and alternative estimation procedures (Tobit and Instrumental Variables regressions).

AB - There is considerable variation in pension systems across countries. Pension funds regulation and supervision are two characteristics of pension systems that exemplify such variation. Pension funds regulation and supervisory activities differ in their degree of intensity and strictness. We investigate to what extent national culture plays a role in explaining differences in approaches to the regulation and supervision of pension funds. As measures of national culture, Hofstede’s cultural dimensions are used. First, we find that countries characterized by higher individualism are strongly related to lower investment restrictions that pension funds are allowed to make. This relationship is found using three different measures of investment restrictions. Second, we find that higher scores on uncertainty avoidance and power distance, and lower scores on individualism are associated with stricter reporting requirements that pension funds have to fulfill. All results are robust to changes in the measures of cultural variables (updated versions of Hofstede’s cultural dimensions) and alternative estimation procedures (Tobit and Instrumental Variables regressions).

M3 - Working paper

BT - Cultural determinants of regulation and supervision of pension funds

PB - Netspar

CY - Tilburg

ER -