Effect of Field Spread on Resting-State Magneto Encephalography Functional Network Analysis: A Computational Modeling Study

S.S. Pereira, R. Hindriks, S. Muhlberg, E. Maris, F. van Ede, A. Griffa, P. Hagmann , G. Deco

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

A popular way to analyze resting-state electroencephalography (EEG) and magneto encephalography (MEG) data is to treat them as a functional network in which sensors are identified with nodes and the interaction between channel time series and the network connections. Although conceptually appealing, the network-theoretical approach to sensor-level EEG and MEG data is challenged by the fact that EEG and MEG time series are mixtures of source activity. It is, therefore, of interest to assess the relationship between functional networks of source activity and the ensuing sensor-level networks. Since these topological features are of high interest in experimental studies, we address the question of to what extent the network topology can be reconstructed from sensor-level functional connectivity (FC) measures in case of MEG data. Simple simulations that consider only a small number of regions do not allow to assess network properties; therefore, we use a diffusion magnetic resonance imaging-constrained whole-brain computational model of resting-state activity. Our motivation lies behind the fact that still many contributions found in the literature perform network analysis at sensor level, and we aim at showing the discrepancies between source- and sensor-level network topologies by using realistic simulations of resting-state cortical activity. Our main findings are that the effect of field spread on network topology depends on the type of interaction (instantaneous or lagged) and leads to an underestimation of lagged FC at sensor level due to instantaneous mixing of cortical signals, instantaneous interaction is more sensitive to field spread than lagged interaction, and discrepancies are reduced when using planar gradiometers rather than axial gradiometers. We, therefore, recommend using lagged interaction measures on planar gradiometer data when investigating network properties of resting-state sensor-level MEG data.
LanguageEnglish
Pages541-557
Number of pages17
JournalBrain Connectivity
Volume7
Issue number9
Early online date27 Oct 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Nov 2017
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Electroencephalography
Diffusion Magnetic Resonance Imaging
Brain

Cite this

Pereira, S.S. ; Hindriks, R. ; Muhlberg, S. ; Maris, E. ; van Ede, F. ; Griffa, A. ; Hagmann , P. ; Deco, G. / Effect of Field Spread on Resting-State Magneto Encephalography Functional Network Analysis: A Computational Modeling Study. In: Brain Connectivity. 2017 ; Vol. 7, No. 9. pp. 541-557.
@article{bcccbb937106437a9756e8eeb5176c83,
title = "Effect of Field Spread on Resting-State Magneto Encephalography Functional Network Analysis: A Computational Modeling Study",
abstract = "A popular way to analyze resting-state electroencephalography (EEG) and magneto encephalography (MEG) data is to treat them as a functional network in which sensors are identified with nodes and the interaction between channel time series and the network connections. Although conceptually appealing, the network-theoretical approach to sensor-level EEG and MEG data is challenged by the fact that EEG and MEG time series are mixtures of source activity. It is, therefore, of interest to assess the relationship between functional networks of source activity and the ensuing sensor-level networks. Since these topological features are of high interest in experimental studies, we address the question of to what extent the network topology can be reconstructed from sensor-level functional connectivity (FC) measures in case of MEG data. Simple simulations that consider only a small number of regions do not allow to assess network properties; therefore, we use a diffusion magnetic resonance imaging-constrained whole-brain computational model of resting-state activity. Our motivation lies behind the fact that still many contributions found in the literature perform network analysis at sensor level, and we aim at showing the discrepancies between source- and sensor-level network topologies by using realistic simulations of resting-state cortical activity. Our main findings are that the effect of field spread on network topology depends on the type of interaction (instantaneous or lagged) and leads to an underestimation of lagged FC at sensor level due to instantaneous mixing of cortical signals, instantaneous interaction is more sensitive to field spread than lagged interaction, and discrepancies are reduced when using planar gradiometers rather than axial gradiometers. We, therefore, recommend using lagged interaction measures on planar gradiometer data when investigating network properties of resting-state sensor-level MEG data.",
author = "S.S. Pereira and R. Hindriks and S. Muhlberg and E. Maris and {van Ede}, F. and A. Griffa and P. Hagmann and G. Deco",
year = "2017",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1089/brain.2017.0525",
language = "English",
volume = "7",
pages = "541--557",
journal = "Brain Connectivity",
issn = "2158-0014",
publisher = "Mary Ann Liebert Inc.",
number = "9",

}

Effect of Field Spread on Resting-State Magneto Encephalography Functional Network Analysis: A Computational Modeling Study. / Pereira, S.S.; Hindriks, R.; Muhlberg, S.; Maris, E.; van Ede, F.; Griffa, A.; Hagmann , P.; Deco, G.

In: Brain Connectivity, Vol. 7, No. 9, 01.11.2017, p. 541-557.

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Effect of Field Spread on Resting-State Magneto Encephalography Functional Network Analysis: A Computational Modeling Study

AU - Pereira, S.S.

AU - Hindriks, R.

AU - Muhlberg, S.

AU - Maris, E.

AU - van Ede, F.

AU - Griffa, A.

AU - Hagmann , P.

AU - Deco, G.

PY - 2017/11/1

Y1 - 2017/11/1

N2 - A popular way to analyze resting-state electroencephalography (EEG) and magneto encephalography (MEG) data is to treat them as a functional network in which sensors are identified with nodes and the interaction between channel time series and the network connections. Although conceptually appealing, the network-theoretical approach to sensor-level EEG and MEG data is challenged by the fact that EEG and MEG time series are mixtures of source activity. It is, therefore, of interest to assess the relationship between functional networks of source activity and the ensuing sensor-level networks. Since these topological features are of high interest in experimental studies, we address the question of to what extent the network topology can be reconstructed from sensor-level functional connectivity (FC) measures in case of MEG data. Simple simulations that consider only a small number of regions do not allow to assess network properties; therefore, we use a diffusion magnetic resonance imaging-constrained whole-brain computational model of resting-state activity. Our motivation lies behind the fact that still many contributions found in the literature perform network analysis at sensor level, and we aim at showing the discrepancies between source- and sensor-level network topologies by using realistic simulations of resting-state cortical activity. Our main findings are that the effect of field spread on network topology depends on the type of interaction (instantaneous or lagged) and leads to an underestimation of lagged FC at sensor level due to instantaneous mixing of cortical signals, instantaneous interaction is more sensitive to field spread than lagged interaction, and discrepancies are reduced when using planar gradiometers rather than axial gradiometers. We, therefore, recommend using lagged interaction measures on planar gradiometer data when investigating network properties of resting-state sensor-level MEG data.

AB - A popular way to analyze resting-state electroencephalography (EEG) and magneto encephalography (MEG) data is to treat them as a functional network in which sensors are identified with nodes and the interaction between channel time series and the network connections. Although conceptually appealing, the network-theoretical approach to sensor-level EEG and MEG data is challenged by the fact that EEG and MEG time series are mixtures of source activity. It is, therefore, of interest to assess the relationship between functional networks of source activity and the ensuing sensor-level networks. Since these topological features are of high interest in experimental studies, we address the question of to what extent the network topology can be reconstructed from sensor-level functional connectivity (FC) measures in case of MEG data. Simple simulations that consider only a small number of regions do not allow to assess network properties; therefore, we use a diffusion magnetic resonance imaging-constrained whole-brain computational model of resting-state activity. Our motivation lies behind the fact that still many contributions found in the literature perform network analysis at sensor level, and we aim at showing the discrepancies between source- and sensor-level network topologies by using realistic simulations of resting-state cortical activity. Our main findings are that the effect of field spread on network topology depends on the type of interaction (instantaneous or lagged) and leads to an underestimation of lagged FC at sensor level due to instantaneous mixing of cortical signals, instantaneous interaction is more sensitive to field spread than lagged interaction, and discrepancies are reduced when using planar gradiometers rather than axial gradiometers. We, therefore, recommend using lagged interaction measures on planar gradiometer data when investigating network properties of resting-state sensor-level MEG data.

U2 - 10.1089/brain.2017.0525

DO - 10.1089/brain.2017.0525

M3 - Article

VL - 7

SP - 541

EP - 557

JO - Brain Connectivity

T2 - Brain Connectivity

JF - Brain Connectivity

SN - 2158-0014

IS - 9

ER -