Efficient search under constraints and not working memory resources supports creative action emergence in a convergent motor task

Dominic Orth, Luke McDonic, Chris Ashbrook, John van der Kamp

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

Creative (original and functional) solutions to problems can be facilitated by guiding search behavior. According to cognitive models, when solving convergent tasks (tasks with few solutions), high available working memory (WM) resources and capacity can guide creative solution emergence via repeated (persistent) search within a solution subcategory. However, no clear associations have been found of WM capacity on creative outcomes when tasks require the individual to enact solutions in divergent doing tasks. This study further tested constraints on WM resources on search behavior and creative outcomes in a convergent doing task. Novices to combat sports were asked to repeatedly strike a target with the intent to achieve an individualized target force. In order to manipulate available WM resources, every ten strikes, participants were asked to recall and then retain a sequence of 5 digits (high load group: n = 21) or 2 digits (low load group: n = 21). The task constraints favored the functionality (or appropriateness) of a qualitatively distinct, non-obvious solution. Functionality was assessed using the force registered for each strike. Originality was assessed in terms of how infrequently actions occurred. Finally, search behavior was quantified based on changes in which limb was used and changes in which part of the limb was used from one strike to the next. There were no significant effects of WM load on creativity outcomes, solution search, or task success. Rather, task success was related to efficient search and creativity. Future research should focus on constraints (other than WM resources) that promote efficient search.

Original languageEnglish
Article number102505
Pages (from-to)1-18
Number of pages18
JournalHuman Movement Science
Volume67
Early online date23 Jul 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Oct 2019

Fingerprint

Short-Term Memory
Creativity
Extremities
Sports

Keywords

  • Affordances
  • Convergent problem solving
  • Exploration
  • Functional movement variability
  • Motor creativity
  • Striking actions
  • Working memory

Cite this

@article{6248e7e82d564e0ca4470a80bb1aec3b,
title = "Efficient search under constraints and not working memory resources supports creative action emergence in a convergent motor task",
abstract = "Creative (original and functional) solutions to problems can be facilitated by guiding search behavior. According to cognitive models, when solving convergent tasks (tasks with few solutions), high available working memory (WM) resources and capacity can guide creative solution emergence via repeated (persistent) search within a solution subcategory. However, no clear associations have been found of WM capacity on creative outcomes when tasks require the individual to enact solutions in divergent doing tasks. This study further tested constraints on WM resources on search behavior and creative outcomes in a convergent doing task. Novices to combat sports were asked to repeatedly strike a target with the intent to achieve an individualized target force. In order to manipulate available WM resources, every ten strikes, participants were asked to recall and then retain a sequence of 5 digits (high load group: n = 21) or 2 digits (low load group: n = 21). The task constraints favored the functionality (or appropriateness) of a qualitatively distinct, non-obvious solution. Functionality was assessed using the force registered for each strike. Originality was assessed in terms of how infrequently actions occurred. Finally, search behavior was quantified based on changes in which limb was used and changes in which part of the limb was used from one strike to the next. There were no significant effects of WM load on creativity outcomes, solution search, or task success. Rather, task success was related to efficient search and creativity. Future research should focus on constraints (other than WM resources) that promote efficient search.",
keywords = "Affordances, Convergent problem solving, Exploration, Functional movement variability, Motor creativity, Striking actions, Working memory",
author = "Dominic Orth and Luke McDonic and Chris Ashbrook and {van der Kamp}, John",
year = "2019",
month = "10",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.humov.2019.102505",
language = "English",
volume = "67",
pages = "1--18",
journal = "Human Movement Science",
issn = "0167-9457",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Efficient search under constraints and not working memory resources supports creative action emergence in a convergent motor task. / Orth, Dominic; McDonic, Luke; Ashbrook, Chris; van der Kamp, John.

In: Human Movement Science, Vol. 67, 102505, 01.10.2019, p. 1-18.

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Efficient search under constraints and not working memory resources supports creative action emergence in a convergent motor task

AU - Orth, Dominic

AU - McDonic, Luke

AU - Ashbrook, Chris

AU - van der Kamp, John

PY - 2019/10/1

Y1 - 2019/10/1

N2 - Creative (original and functional) solutions to problems can be facilitated by guiding search behavior. According to cognitive models, when solving convergent tasks (tasks with few solutions), high available working memory (WM) resources and capacity can guide creative solution emergence via repeated (persistent) search within a solution subcategory. However, no clear associations have been found of WM capacity on creative outcomes when tasks require the individual to enact solutions in divergent doing tasks. This study further tested constraints on WM resources on search behavior and creative outcomes in a convergent doing task. Novices to combat sports were asked to repeatedly strike a target with the intent to achieve an individualized target force. In order to manipulate available WM resources, every ten strikes, participants were asked to recall and then retain a sequence of 5 digits (high load group: n = 21) or 2 digits (low load group: n = 21). The task constraints favored the functionality (or appropriateness) of a qualitatively distinct, non-obvious solution. Functionality was assessed using the force registered for each strike. Originality was assessed in terms of how infrequently actions occurred. Finally, search behavior was quantified based on changes in which limb was used and changes in which part of the limb was used from one strike to the next. There were no significant effects of WM load on creativity outcomes, solution search, or task success. Rather, task success was related to efficient search and creativity. Future research should focus on constraints (other than WM resources) that promote efficient search.

AB - Creative (original and functional) solutions to problems can be facilitated by guiding search behavior. According to cognitive models, when solving convergent tasks (tasks with few solutions), high available working memory (WM) resources and capacity can guide creative solution emergence via repeated (persistent) search within a solution subcategory. However, no clear associations have been found of WM capacity on creative outcomes when tasks require the individual to enact solutions in divergent doing tasks. This study further tested constraints on WM resources on search behavior and creative outcomes in a convergent doing task. Novices to combat sports were asked to repeatedly strike a target with the intent to achieve an individualized target force. In order to manipulate available WM resources, every ten strikes, participants were asked to recall and then retain a sequence of 5 digits (high load group: n = 21) or 2 digits (low load group: n = 21). The task constraints favored the functionality (or appropriateness) of a qualitatively distinct, non-obvious solution. Functionality was assessed using the force registered for each strike. Originality was assessed in terms of how infrequently actions occurred. Finally, search behavior was quantified based on changes in which limb was used and changes in which part of the limb was used from one strike to the next. There were no significant effects of WM load on creativity outcomes, solution search, or task success. Rather, task success was related to efficient search and creativity. Future research should focus on constraints (other than WM resources) that promote efficient search.

KW - Affordances

KW - Convergent problem solving

KW - Exploration

KW - Functional movement variability

KW - Motor creativity

KW - Striking actions

KW - Working memory

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85069705596&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85069705596&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.humov.2019.102505

DO - 10.1016/j.humov.2019.102505

M3 - Article

VL - 67

SP - 1

EP - 18

JO - Human Movement Science

JF - Human Movement Science

SN - 0167-9457

M1 - 102505

ER -