Exploitation

Research output: Chapter in Book / Report / Conference proceedingEntry for encyclopedia/dictionaryAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

The concept of exploitation is often invoked in situations where relatively impoverished people are treated unfairly in economic and social contexts. While the claim that exploitation involves taking unfair advantage is broadly accepted, there is little consensus about what fairness requires and whether unfairness is seriously wrong in the context of exchanges. One family of accounts claims that exploitation involves the maldistribution of resources, either because exploitative transactions result in distributions that violate substantive norms of fairness, or because procedural flaws in the way exploitative transactions come about entail that their outcomes are unfair.

A second, domination-based approach to exploitation claims that the moral flaw embodied by exploitative relations is the exploiter’s disrespectful use of his power over the exploitee. While exploiters’ domination of others may lead to maldistributions, defenders of the domination-based approach argue that distributive unfairness is neither necessary nor sufficient for exploitative relations.

These approaches both face two kinds of challenges. The first concerns the scope. Neither appears to provide necessary and sufficient conditions that are adequate to capture all and only cases commonly described as exploitation. The second concerns the normative status. Exploitation is typically assumed to be morally impermissible, yet neither approach seems to satisfactorily explain how exploitations that nevertheless generate significant welfare gains for both parties can be wrong.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationOxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics
EditorsWilliam R. Thompson
PublisherOxford, UK: Oxford University Press
ISBN (Electronic)9780190228637
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Publication series

NameOxford Research Encyclopedias
PublisherOUP

Fingerprint

exploitation
domination
fairness
transaction
welfare
resources
economics

Cite this

Ferguson, B. (2019). Exploitation. In W. R. Thompson (Ed.), Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics (Oxford Research Encyclopedias). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.113
Ferguson, B. / Exploitation. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. editor / William R. Thompson. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 2019. (Oxford Research Encyclopedias).
@inbook{c91a650eaa334c24baccc0c2e3a9fc30,
title = "Exploitation",
abstract = "The concept of exploitation is often invoked in situations where relatively impoverished people are treated unfairly in economic and social contexts. While the claim that exploitation involves taking unfair advantage is broadly accepted, there is little consensus about what fairness requires and whether unfairness is seriously wrong in the context of exchanges. One family of accounts claims that exploitation involves the maldistribution of resources, either because exploitative transactions result in distributions that violate substantive norms of fairness, or because procedural flaws in the way exploitative transactions come about entail that their outcomes are unfair.A second, domination-based approach to exploitation claims that the moral flaw embodied by exploitative relations is the exploiter’s disrespectful use of his power over the exploitee. While exploiters’ domination of others may lead to maldistributions, defenders of the domination-based approach argue that distributive unfairness is neither necessary nor sufficient for exploitative relations.These approaches both face two kinds of challenges. The first concerns the scope. Neither appears to provide necessary and sufficient conditions that are adequate to capture all and only cases commonly described as exploitation. The second concerns the normative status. Exploitation is typically assumed to be morally impermissible, yet neither approach seems to satisfactorily explain how exploitations that nevertheless generate significant welfare gains for both parties can be wrong.",
author = "B. Ferguson",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.113",
language = "English",
series = "Oxford Research Encyclopedias",
publisher = "Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press",
editor = "Thompson, {William R.}",
booktitle = "Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics",

}

Ferguson, B 2019, Exploitation. in WR Thompson (ed.), Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. Oxford Research Encyclopedias, Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.113

Exploitation. / Ferguson, B.

Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. ed. / William R. Thompson. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 2019. (Oxford Research Encyclopedias).

Research output: Chapter in Book / Report / Conference proceedingEntry for encyclopedia/dictionaryAcademicpeer-review

TY - CHAP

T1 - Exploitation

AU - Ferguson, B.

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - The concept of exploitation is often invoked in situations where relatively impoverished people are treated unfairly in economic and social contexts. While the claim that exploitation involves taking unfair advantage is broadly accepted, there is little consensus about what fairness requires and whether unfairness is seriously wrong in the context of exchanges. One family of accounts claims that exploitation involves the maldistribution of resources, either because exploitative transactions result in distributions that violate substantive norms of fairness, or because procedural flaws in the way exploitative transactions come about entail that their outcomes are unfair.A second, domination-based approach to exploitation claims that the moral flaw embodied by exploitative relations is the exploiter’s disrespectful use of his power over the exploitee. While exploiters’ domination of others may lead to maldistributions, defenders of the domination-based approach argue that distributive unfairness is neither necessary nor sufficient for exploitative relations.These approaches both face two kinds of challenges. The first concerns the scope. Neither appears to provide necessary and sufficient conditions that are adequate to capture all and only cases commonly described as exploitation. The second concerns the normative status. Exploitation is typically assumed to be morally impermissible, yet neither approach seems to satisfactorily explain how exploitations that nevertheless generate significant welfare gains for both parties can be wrong.

AB - The concept of exploitation is often invoked in situations where relatively impoverished people are treated unfairly in economic and social contexts. While the claim that exploitation involves taking unfair advantage is broadly accepted, there is little consensus about what fairness requires and whether unfairness is seriously wrong in the context of exchanges. One family of accounts claims that exploitation involves the maldistribution of resources, either because exploitative transactions result in distributions that violate substantive norms of fairness, or because procedural flaws in the way exploitative transactions come about entail that their outcomes are unfair.A second, domination-based approach to exploitation claims that the moral flaw embodied by exploitative relations is the exploiter’s disrespectful use of his power over the exploitee. While exploiters’ domination of others may lead to maldistributions, defenders of the domination-based approach argue that distributive unfairness is neither necessary nor sufficient for exploitative relations.These approaches both face two kinds of challenges. The first concerns the scope. Neither appears to provide necessary and sufficient conditions that are adequate to capture all and only cases commonly described as exploitation. The second concerns the normative status. Exploitation is typically assumed to be morally impermissible, yet neither approach seems to satisfactorily explain how exploitations that nevertheless generate significant welfare gains for both parties can be wrong.

U2 - 10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.113

DO - 10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.113

M3 - Entry for encyclopedia/dictionary

T3 - Oxford Research Encyclopedias

BT - Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics

A2 - Thompson, William R.

PB - Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press

ER -

Ferguson B. Exploitation. In Thompson WR, editor, Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. 2019. (Oxford Research Encyclopedias). https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.113