Forensics for Dummies? Equality of arms in and on trial in Dutch criminal courts.

J.J. van der Kemp, S. Stalman

Research output: Contribution to ConferencePosterOther research output

Abstract

Forensic disciplines such as DNA-matching, pathology and psychology are often requested to report in criminal cases. Within the Dutch legal system forensic experts are court appointed and little use of second opinion or contra-expertise by the defence is seen. This makes that forensic reports written by expert witnesses or forensic crime scene investigators must be understood by lawyers – without a forensic background - in order to discuss these in court. So how do lawyers use forensic reports in their defence cases? Do lawyers contest the forensic reports on its content or procedures? A survey conducted among criminal lawyers was done to see on what elements forensic reports are debated in court and if different styles of reporting or outside expertise would be considered beneficial. This last element is quite uncommon within the Dutch law practice. This study addresses both equality of arms issues as well as the importance of interpretation of forensic evidence in criminal cases by non-forensic experts.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 2009
EventAmerican Society of Criminology - Annual Meeting 2009 - Philadelphia, USA
Duration: 4 Nov 20097 Nov 2009

Conference

ConferenceAmerican Society of Criminology - Annual Meeting 2009
Period4/11/097/11/09

Fingerprint

lawyer
equality
expert
expertise
legal system
pathology
witness
psychology
offense
interpretation
Law
evidence

Bibliographical note

Place of publication: Philadelphia, USA

Cite this

van der Kemp, J. J., & Stalman, S. (2009). Forensics for Dummies? Equality of arms in and on trial in Dutch criminal courts.. Poster session presented at American Society of Criminology - Annual Meeting 2009, .
van der Kemp, J.J. ; Stalman, S. / Forensics for Dummies? Equality of arms in and on trial in Dutch criminal courts. Poster session presented at American Society of Criminology - Annual Meeting 2009, .
@conference{c2911b1167144c19bdb66009267639af,
title = "Forensics for Dummies? Equality of arms in and on trial in Dutch criminal courts.",
abstract = "Forensic disciplines such as DNA-matching, pathology and psychology are often requested to report in criminal cases. Within the Dutch legal system forensic experts are court appointed and little use of second opinion or contra-expertise by the defence is seen. This makes that forensic reports written by expert witnesses or forensic crime scene investigators must be understood by lawyers – without a forensic background - in order to discuss these in court. So how do lawyers use forensic reports in their defence cases? Do lawyers contest the forensic reports on its content or procedures? A survey conducted among criminal lawyers was done to see on what elements forensic reports are debated in court and if different styles of reporting or outside expertise would be considered beneficial. This last element is quite uncommon within the Dutch law practice. This study addresses both equality of arms issues as well as the importance of interpretation of forensic evidence in criminal cases by non-forensic experts.",
author = "{van der Kemp}, J.J. and S. Stalman",
note = "Place of publication: Philadelphia, USA; American Society of Criminology - Annual Meeting 2009 ; Conference date: 04-11-2009 Through 07-11-2009",
year = "2009",
language = "English",

}

van der Kemp, JJ & Stalman, S 2009, 'Forensics for Dummies? Equality of arms in and on trial in Dutch criminal courts.' American Society of Criminology - Annual Meeting 2009, 4/11/09 - 7/11/09, .

Forensics for Dummies? Equality of arms in and on trial in Dutch criminal courts. / van der Kemp, J.J.; Stalman, S.

2009. Poster session presented at American Society of Criminology - Annual Meeting 2009, .

Research output: Contribution to ConferencePosterOther research output

TY - CONF

T1 - Forensics for Dummies? Equality of arms in and on trial in Dutch criminal courts.

AU - van der Kemp, J.J.

AU - Stalman, S.

N1 - Place of publication: Philadelphia, USA

PY - 2009

Y1 - 2009

N2 - Forensic disciplines such as DNA-matching, pathology and psychology are often requested to report in criminal cases. Within the Dutch legal system forensic experts are court appointed and little use of second opinion or contra-expertise by the defence is seen. This makes that forensic reports written by expert witnesses or forensic crime scene investigators must be understood by lawyers – without a forensic background - in order to discuss these in court. So how do lawyers use forensic reports in their defence cases? Do lawyers contest the forensic reports on its content or procedures? A survey conducted among criminal lawyers was done to see on what elements forensic reports are debated in court and if different styles of reporting or outside expertise would be considered beneficial. This last element is quite uncommon within the Dutch law practice. This study addresses both equality of arms issues as well as the importance of interpretation of forensic evidence in criminal cases by non-forensic experts.

AB - Forensic disciplines such as DNA-matching, pathology and psychology are often requested to report in criminal cases. Within the Dutch legal system forensic experts are court appointed and little use of second opinion or contra-expertise by the defence is seen. This makes that forensic reports written by expert witnesses or forensic crime scene investigators must be understood by lawyers – without a forensic background - in order to discuss these in court. So how do lawyers use forensic reports in their defence cases? Do lawyers contest the forensic reports on its content or procedures? A survey conducted among criminal lawyers was done to see on what elements forensic reports are debated in court and if different styles of reporting or outside expertise would be considered beneficial. This last element is quite uncommon within the Dutch law practice. This study addresses both equality of arms issues as well as the importance of interpretation of forensic evidence in criminal cases by non-forensic experts.

M3 - Poster

ER -

van der Kemp JJ, Stalman S. Forensics for Dummies? Equality of arms in and on trial in Dutch criminal courts.. 2009. Poster session presented at American Society of Criminology - Annual Meeting 2009, .