Gold Open Access Publishing in Mega Journals: Developing Countries Pay the Price of Western Premium Academic Output

J. Ellers, T.W. Crowther, J.A. Harvey

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

Open access publishing (OAP) makes research output freely available, and several national governments have now made OAP mandatory for all publicly funded research. Gold OAP is a common form of OAP where the author pays an article processing charge (APC) to make the article freely available to readers. However, gold OAP is a cause for concern because it drives a redistribution of valuable research money to support open access papers in ‘mega-journals’ with more permissive acceptance criteria. We present a data-driven evaluation of the financial ramifications of gold OAP and provide evidence that gold OAP in mega-journals is biased toward Western industrialized countries. From 2011 to 2015, the period of our data collection, countries with developing economies had a disproportionately greater share of articles published in the lower-tier mega-journals and thus paid article APCs that cross-subsidize publications in the top-tier journals of the same publisher. Conversely, scientists from Western developed countries had a disproportionately greater share of articles published in those same top-tier journals. The global inequity of the cross-subsidizing APC model was demonstrated across five different mega-journals, showing that the issue is a common problem. We need to develop stringent and fair criteria that address the global financial implications of OAP, as publication fees should reflect the real cost of publishing and be transparent for authors.
LanguageEnglish
Pages89-102
JournalJournal of Scholarly Publishing
Volume49
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - 2017

Fingerprint

open access
premium
gold
Developing countries
Gold
developing country
Processing
redistribution
fee
data analysis
money
acceptance
economy
cause
costs

Cite this

@article{2d2a144ec1fa4061854ac97dd31c6cd1,
title = "Gold Open Access Publishing in Mega Journals: Developing Countries Pay the Price of Western Premium Academic Output",
abstract = "Open access publishing (OAP) makes research output freely available, and several national governments have now made OAP mandatory for all publicly funded research. Gold OAP is a common form of OAP where the author pays an article processing charge (APC) to make the article freely available to readers. However, gold OAP is a cause for concern because it drives a redistribution of valuable research money to support open access papers in ‘mega-journals’ with more permissive acceptance criteria. We present a data-driven evaluation of the financial ramifications of gold OAP and provide evidence that gold OAP in mega-journals is biased toward Western industrialized countries. From 2011 to 2015, the period of our data collection, countries with developing economies had a disproportionately greater share of articles published in the lower-tier mega-journals and thus paid article APCs that cross-subsidize publications in the top-tier journals of the same publisher. Conversely, scientists from Western developed countries had a disproportionately greater share of articles published in those same top-tier journals. The global inequity of the cross-subsidizing APC model was demonstrated across five different mega-journals, showing that the issue is a common problem. We need to develop stringent and fair criteria that address the global financial implications of OAP, as publication fees should reflect the real cost of publishing and be transparent for authors.",
author = "J. Ellers and T.W. Crowther and J.A. Harvey",
year = "2017",
doi = "10.3138/jsp.49.1.89",
language = "English",
volume = "49",
pages = "89--102",
journal = "Journal of Scholarly Publishing",
issn = "1198-9742",
publisher = "University of Toronto Press",
number = "1",

}

Gold Open Access Publishing in Mega Journals: Developing Countries Pay the Price of Western Premium Academic Output. / Ellers, J.; Crowther, T.W.; Harvey, J.A.

In: Journal of Scholarly Publishing , Vol. 49, No. 1, 2017, p. 89-102.

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Gold Open Access Publishing in Mega Journals: Developing Countries Pay the Price of Western Premium Academic Output

AU - Ellers,J.

AU - Crowther,T.W.

AU - Harvey,J.A.

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - Open access publishing (OAP) makes research output freely available, and several national governments have now made OAP mandatory for all publicly funded research. Gold OAP is a common form of OAP where the author pays an article processing charge (APC) to make the article freely available to readers. However, gold OAP is a cause for concern because it drives a redistribution of valuable research money to support open access papers in ‘mega-journals’ with more permissive acceptance criteria. We present a data-driven evaluation of the financial ramifications of gold OAP and provide evidence that gold OAP in mega-journals is biased toward Western industrialized countries. From 2011 to 2015, the period of our data collection, countries with developing economies had a disproportionately greater share of articles published in the lower-tier mega-journals and thus paid article APCs that cross-subsidize publications in the top-tier journals of the same publisher. Conversely, scientists from Western developed countries had a disproportionately greater share of articles published in those same top-tier journals. The global inequity of the cross-subsidizing APC model was demonstrated across five different mega-journals, showing that the issue is a common problem. We need to develop stringent and fair criteria that address the global financial implications of OAP, as publication fees should reflect the real cost of publishing and be transparent for authors.

AB - Open access publishing (OAP) makes research output freely available, and several national governments have now made OAP mandatory for all publicly funded research. Gold OAP is a common form of OAP where the author pays an article processing charge (APC) to make the article freely available to readers. However, gold OAP is a cause for concern because it drives a redistribution of valuable research money to support open access papers in ‘mega-journals’ with more permissive acceptance criteria. We present a data-driven evaluation of the financial ramifications of gold OAP and provide evidence that gold OAP in mega-journals is biased toward Western industrialized countries. From 2011 to 2015, the period of our data collection, countries with developing economies had a disproportionately greater share of articles published in the lower-tier mega-journals and thus paid article APCs that cross-subsidize publications in the top-tier journals of the same publisher. Conversely, scientists from Western developed countries had a disproportionately greater share of articles published in those same top-tier journals. The global inequity of the cross-subsidizing APC model was demonstrated across five different mega-journals, showing that the issue is a common problem. We need to develop stringent and fair criteria that address the global financial implications of OAP, as publication fees should reflect the real cost of publishing and be transparent for authors.

U2 - 10.3138/jsp.49.1.89

DO - 10.3138/jsp.49.1.89

M3 - Article

VL - 49

SP - 89

EP - 102

JO - Journal of Scholarly Publishing

T2 - Journal of Scholarly Publishing

JF - Journal of Scholarly Publishing

SN - 1198-9742

IS - 1

ER -