Lost in Space? Cognitive Fit and Cognitive Load in 3D Virtual Environments

S.F. van der Land, A.P. Schouten, J.F.M. Feldberg, B.J. van den Hooff, M.H. Huysman

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

In this paper, we explore how visual representations of information in 3D virtual environments (3DVEs) supports both individual and shared understanding, and consequently contribute to group decision making in tasks with a strong visual component. We integrate insights from cognitive fit theory and cognitive load theory in order to formulate hypotheses about how 3DVEs can contribute to individual understanding, shared understanding, and group decision making. We discuss the results of an experiment in which 192 participants, in 3-person teams, were asked to select an apartment. As proposed by cognitive fit theory, our results indicate that 3DVEs are indeed more effective in supporting individual understanding than 2D information presentations. Next, in line with cognitive load theory, the static presentation of 3D information turns out to be more effective in supporting shared understanding and group decision making than an immersive 3DVE. Our results suggest that although the 3DVE capabilities of realism, immersion and interactivity contribute to individual understanding, these capabilities combined with the interaction and negotiation processes required for reaching a shared understanding (and group decision), increases cognitive load and makes group processes inefficient. The implications of this paper for research and practice are discussed. © 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1054-1064
JournalComputers in Human Behavior
Volume29
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2013

Fingerprint

Virtual reality
Decision Making
Decision making
Group Processes
Negotiating
Immersion
Research
Virtual Environments
Cognitive Load
Group Decision Making
Experiments

Cite this

@article{ceda15153cdd4159bd39c09711edfc18,
title = "Lost in Space? Cognitive Fit and Cognitive Load in 3D Virtual Environments",
abstract = "In this paper, we explore how visual representations of information in 3D virtual environments (3DVEs) supports both individual and shared understanding, and consequently contribute to group decision making in tasks with a strong visual component. We integrate insights from cognitive fit theory and cognitive load theory in order to formulate hypotheses about how 3DVEs can contribute to individual understanding, shared understanding, and group decision making. We discuss the results of an experiment in which 192 participants, in 3-person teams, were asked to select an apartment. As proposed by cognitive fit theory, our results indicate that 3DVEs are indeed more effective in supporting individual understanding than 2D information presentations. Next, in line with cognitive load theory, the static presentation of 3D information turns out to be more effective in supporting shared understanding and group decision making than an immersive 3DVE. Our results suggest that although the 3DVE capabilities of realism, immersion and interactivity contribute to individual understanding, these capabilities combined with the interaction and negotiation processes required for reaching a shared understanding (and group decision), increases cognitive load and makes group processes inefficient. The implications of this paper for research and practice are discussed. {\circledC} 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.",
author = "{van der Land}, S.F. and A.P. Schouten and J.F.M. Feldberg and {van den Hooff}, B.J. and M.H. Huysman",
year = "2013",
doi = "10.1016/j.chb.2012.09.006",
language = "English",
volume = "29",
pages = "1054--1064",
journal = "Computers in Human Behavior",
issn = "0747-5632",
publisher = "Pergamon",
number = "3",

}

Lost in Space? Cognitive Fit and Cognitive Load in 3D Virtual Environments. / van der Land, S.F.; Schouten, A.P.; Feldberg, J.F.M.; van den Hooff, B.J.; Huysman, M.H.

In: Computers in Human Behavior, Vol. 29, No. 3, 2013, p. 1054-1064.

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Lost in Space? Cognitive Fit and Cognitive Load in 3D Virtual Environments

AU - van der Land, S.F.

AU - Schouten, A.P.

AU - Feldberg, J.F.M.

AU - van den Hooff, B.J.

AU - Huysman, M.H.

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - In this paper, we explore how visual representations of information in 3D virtual environments (3DVEs) supports both individual and shared understanding, and consequently contribute to group decision making in tasks with a strong visual component. We integrate insights from cognitive fit theory and cognitive load theory in order to formulate hypotheses about how 3DVEs can contribute to individual understanding, shared understanding, and group decision making. We discuss the results of an experiment in which 192 participants, in 3-person teams, were asked to select an apartment. As proposed by cognitive fit theory, our results indicate that 3DVEs are indeed more effective in supporting individual understanding than 2D information presentations. Next, in line with cognitive load theory, the static presentation of 3D information turns out to be more effective in supporting shared understanding and group decision making than an immersive 3DVE. Our results suggest that although the 3DVE capabilities of realism, immersion and interactivity contribute to individual understanding, these capabilities combined with the interaction and negotiation processes required for reaching a shared understanding (and group decision), increases cognitive load and makes group processes inefficient. The implications of this paper for research and practice are discussed. © 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

AB - In this paper, we explore how visual representations of information in 3D virtual environments (3DVEs) supports both individual and shared understanding, and consequently contribute to group decision making in tasks with a strong visual component. We integrate insights from cognitive fit theory and cognitive load theory in order to formulate hypotheses about how 3DVEs can contribute to individual understanding, shared understanding, and group decision making. We discuss the results of an experiment in which 192 participants, in 3-person teams, were asked to select an apartment. As proposed by cognitive fit theory, our results indicate that 3DVEs are indeed more effective in supporting individual understanding than 2D information presentations. Next, in line with cognitive load theory, the static presentation of 3D information turns out to be more effective in supporting shared understanding and group decision making than an immersive 3DVE. Our results suggest that although the 3DVE capabilities of realism, immersion and interactivity contribute to individual understanding, these capabilities combined with the interaction and negotiation processes required for reaching a shared understanding (and group decision), increases cognitive load and makes group processes inefficient. The implications of this paper for research and practice are discussed. © 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

U2 - 10.1016/j.chb.2012.09.006

DO - 10.1016/j.chb.2012.09.006

M3 - Article

VL - 29

SP - 1054

EP - 1064

JO - Computers in Human Behavior

JF - Computers in Human Behavior

SN - 0747-5632

IS - 3

ER -