The Disputed Origins of Dutch Calvinism: Religious Refugees in the Historiography of the Dutch Reformation

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

According to historiographical convention, the experience of exile by Protestants from the Habsburg Netherlands between the 1550s and the early 1570s played a critical role in promoting confessional Calvinism in the early Dutch Republic. But there are too many problems in the evidentiary basis to sustain this conclusion. This essay traces the historiography on the Dutch Reformation in order to isolate where and why this idea emerged. It demonstrates that no specific role for religious refugees in the development of Dutch Calvinism can be found in historical writing from the late sixteenth to the mid-nineteenth century. Only in the late nineteenth century, during a debate about the role of the Dutch Reformed Church in the Netherlands, did the experiences of religious refugees come to take on a specific role in explaining the development of Dutch Calvinism. The idea first emerged among Neo-Calvinists who critiqued state supervision of their church. By the twentieth century, it came to be used by orthodox and moderate Reformed Protestants, as well as liberal and secular academic historians. This paper thus demonstrates that this key interpretive framework for understanding the Dutch Reformation was the product not of developments in the sixteenth-century Habsburg Netherlands, but of religious politics in the Kingdom of the Netherlands in the late nineteenth century.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)398-426
Number of pages29
JournalChurch History
Volume86
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2017

Fingerprint

Calvinism
reformation
historiography
refugee
Netherlands
nineteenth century
church
exile
sixteenth century
supervision
historian
experience
twentieth century
politics
The Netherlands
Religion
Refugees
Historiography
Reformation

Cite this

@article{a48315bba71041898ee3b04321e34795,
title = "The Disputed Origins of Dutch Calvinism: Religious Refugees in the Historiography of the Dutch Reformation",
abstract = "According to historiographical convention, the experience of exile by Protestants from the Habsburg Netherlands between the 1550s and the early 1570s played a critical role in promoting confessional Calvinism in the early Dutch Republic. But there are too many problems in the evidentiary basis to sustain this conclusion. This essay traces the historiography on the Dutch Reformation in order to isolate where and why this idea emerged. It demonstrates that no specific role for religious refugees in the development of Dutch Calvinism can be found in historical writing from the late sixteenth to the mid-nineteenth century. Only in the late nineteenth century, during a debate about the role of the Dutch Reformed Church in the Netherlands, did the experiences of religious refugees come to take on a specific role in explaining the development of Dutch Calvinism. The idea first emerged among Neo-Calvinists who critiqued state supervision of their church. By the twentieth century, it came to be used by orthodox and moderate Reformed Protestants, as well as liberal and secular academic historians. This paper thus demonstrates that this key interpretive framework for understanding the Dutch Reformation was the product not of developments in the sixteenth-century Habsburg Netherlands, but of religious politics in the Kingdom of the Netherlands in the late nineteenth century.",
author = "Jesse Spohnholz and {Van Veen}, {Mirjam G.K.}",
year = "2017",
doi = "10.1017/S0009640717000567",
language = "English",
volume = "86",
pages = "398--426",
journal = "Church History",
issn = "0009-6407",
publisher = "Brill",
number = "2",

}

The Disputed Origins of Dutch Calvinism: Religious Refugees in the Historiography of the Dutch Reformation. / Spohnholz, Jesse; Van Veen, Mirjam G.K.

In: Church History, Vol. 86, No. 2, 2017, p. 398-426.

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Disputed Origins of Dutch Calvinism: Religious Refugees in the Historiography of the Dutch Reformation

AU - Spohnholz, Jesse

AU - Van Veen, Mirjam G.K.

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - According to historiographical convention, the experience of exile by Protestants from the Habsburg Netherlands between the 1550s and the early 1570s played a critical role in promoting confessional Calvinism in the early Dutch Republic. But there are too many problems in the evidentiary basis to sustain this conclusion. This essay traces the historiography on the Dutch Reformation in order to isolate where and why this idea emerged. It demonstrates that no specific role for religious refugees in the development of Dutch Calvinism can be found in historical writing from the late sixteenth to the mid-nineteenth century. Only in the late nineteenth century, during a debate about the role of the Dutch Reformed Church in the Netherlands, did the experiences of religious refugees come to take on a specific role in explaining the development of Dutch Calvinism. The idea first emerged among Neo-Calvinists who critiqued state supervision of their church. By the twentieth century, it came to be used by orthodox and moderate Reformed Protestants, as well as liberal and secular academic historians. This paper thus demonstrates that this key interpretive framework for understanding the Dutch Reformation was the product not of developments in the sixteenth-century Habsburg Netherlands, but of religious politics in the Kingdom of the Netherlands in the late nineteenth century.

AB - According to historiographical convention, the experience of exile by Protestants from the Habsburg Netherlands between the 1550s and the early 1570s played a critical role in promoting confessional Calvinism in the early Dutch Republic. But there are too many problems in the evidentiary basis to sustain this conclusion. This essay traces the historiography on the Dutch Reformation in order to isolate where and why this idea emerged. It demonstrates that no specific role for religious refugees in the development of Dutch Calvinism can be found in historical writing from the late sixteenth to the mid-nineteenth century. Only in the late nineteenth century, during a debate about the role of the Dutch Reformed Church in the Netherlands, did the experiences of religious refugees come to take on a specific role in explaining the development of Dutch Calvinism. The idea first emerged among Neo-Calvinists who critiqued state supervision of their church. By the twentieth century, it came to be used by orthodox and moderate Reformed Protestants, as well as liberal and secular academic historians. This paper thus demonstrates that this key interpretive framework for understanding the Dutch Reformation was the product not of developments in the sixteenth-century Habsburg Netherlands, but of religious politics in the Kingdom of the Netherlands in the late nineteenth century.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85028356096&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85028356096&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1017/S0009640717000567

DO - 10.1017/S0009640717000567

M3 - Article

VL - 86

SP - 398

EP - 426

JO - Church History

JF - Church History

SN - 0009-6407

IS - 2

ER -