Transparency of Environmental Computer Models

M.G. de Vos, J.L. Top, W.R. van Hage, A.Th. Schreiber

Research output: Chapter in Book / Report / Conference proceedingConference contributionAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

Environmental computer models are considered essential tools in supporting environmental decision making, but their main value is that they allow a better understanding of our complex environment. Despite numerous attempts to promote good modelling practice, transparency of current environmental computer models is limited, which hinders progress in both science and policy making. An important cause is that the structure, meaning and context of environmental computer models is often not clear for other people than the model developers. In the proposed research project we would like to find out whether it is possible to increase the transparency of environmental computer models by making their underlying conceptual model explicit. In preliminary research we identi ed the following challenges: 1) many model developers are mainly focused on the computational instead of the descriptive aspects of computer models 2) many environmental modellers may not consider the lack of transparency a big problem nor do they see computer scientists as natural partners in cooperation. However, we think that both environmental and computer science could bene t from an interdisciplinary or even a totally integrated approach. We expect that ex- perimenting with tools and methods from computer science could teach us important lessons on the practice of environmental modelling and hopefully guide us to this novel, integrated way of performing e-science.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceedings of the AISB 2013 symposium on enabling Domain experts to use Formalized reasoning (DoForm)
Place of PublicationExeter, UK
Number of pages4
Publication statusPublished - 2013

Fingerprint

Transparency
Computer science
Decision making

Cite this

de Vos, M. G., Top, J. L., van Hage, W. R., & Schreiber, A. T. (2013). Transparency of Environmental Computer Models. In Proceedings of the AISB 2013 symposium on enabling Domain experts to use Formalized reasoning (DoForm) Exeter, UK.
de Vos, M.G. ; Top, J.L. ; van Hage, W.R. ; Schreiber, A.Th. / Transparency of Environmental Computer Models. Proceedings of the AISB 2013 symposium on enabling Domain experts to use Formalized reasoning (DoForm). Exeter, UK, 2013.
@inproceedings{2fd2c677a44d47d5aa7512496e28256e,
title = "Transparency of Environmental Computer Models",
abstract = "Environmental computer models are considered essential tools in supporting environmental decision making, but their main value is that they allow a better understanding of our complex environment. Despite numerous attempts to promote good modelling practice, transparency of current environmental computer models is limited, which hinders progress in both science and policy making. An important cause is that the structure, meaning and context of environmental computer models is often not clear for other people than the model developers. In the proposed research project we would like to find out whether it is possible to increase the transparency of environmental computer models by making their underlying conceptual model explicit. In preliminary research we identi ed the following challenges: 1) many model developers are mainly focused on the computational instead of the descriptive aspects of computer models 2) many environmental modellers may not consider the lack of transparency a big problem nor do they see computer scientists as natural partners in cooperation. However, we think that both environmental and computer science could bene t from an interdisciplinary or even a totally integrated approach. We expect that ex- perimenting with tools and methods from computer science could teach us important lessons on the practice of environmental modelling and hopefully guide us to this novel, integrated way of performing e-science.",
author = "{de Vos}, M.G. and J.L. Top and {van Hage}, W.R. and A.Th. Schreiber",
year = "2013",
language = "English",
booktitle = "Proceedings of the AISB 2013 symposium on enabling Domain experts to use Formalized reasoning (DoForm)",

}

de Vos, MG, Top, JL, van Hage, WR & Schreiber, AT 2013, Transparency of Environmental Computer Models. in Proceedings of the AISB 2013 symposium on enabling Domain experts to use Formalized reasoning (DoForm). Exeter, UK.

Transparency of Environmental Computer Models. / de Vos, M.G.; Top, J.L.; van Hage, W.R.; Schreiber, A.Th.

Proceedings of the AISB 2013 symposium on enabling Domain experts to use Formalized reasoning (DoForm). Exeter, UK, 2013.

Research output: Chapter in Book / Report / Conference proceedingConference contributionAcademicpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - Transparency of Environmental Computer Models

AU - de Vos, M.G.

AU - Top, J.L.

AU - van Hage, W.R.

AU - Schreiber, A.Th.

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - Environmental computer models are considered essential tools in supporting environmental decision making, but their main value is that they allow a better understanding of our complex environment. Despite numerous attempts to promote good modelling practice, transparency of current environmental computer models is limited, which hinders progress in both science and policy making. An important cause is that the structure, meaning and context of environmental computer models is often not clear for other people than the model developers. In the proposed research project we would like to find out whether it is possible to increase the transparency of environmental computer models by making their underlying conceptual model explicit. In preliminary research we identi ed the following challenges: 1) many model developers are mainly focused on the computational instead of the descriptive aspects of computer models 2) many environmental modellers may not consider the lack of transparency a big problem nor do they see computer scientists as natural partners in cooperation. However, we think that both environmental and computer science could bene t from an interdisciplinary or even a totally integrated approach. We expect that ex- perimenting with tools and methods from computer science could teach us important lessons on the practice of environmental modelling and hopefully guide us to this novel, integrated way of performing e-science.

AB - Environmental computer models are considered essential tools in supporting environmental decision making, but their main value is that they allow a better understanding of our complex environment. Despite numerous attempts to promote good modelling practice, transparency of current environmental computer models is limited, which hinders progress in both science and policy making. An important cause is that the structure, meaning and context of environmental computer models is often not clear for other people than the model developers. In the proposed research project we would like to find out whether it is possible to increase the transparency of environmental computer models by making their underlying conceptual model explicit. In preliminary research we identi ed the following challenges: 1) many model developers are mainly focused on the computational instead of the descriptive aspects of computer models 2) many environmental modellers may not consider the lack of transparency a big problem nor do they see computer scientists as natural partners in cooperation. However, we think that both environmental and computer science could bene t from an interdisciplinary or even a totally integrated approach. We expect that ex- perimenting with tools and methods from computer science could teach us important lessons on the practice of environmental modelling and hopefully guide us to this novel, integrated way of performing e-science.

M3 - Conference contribution

BT - Proceedings of the AISB 2013 symposium on enabling Domain experts to use Formalized reasoning (DoForm)

CY - Exeter, UK

ER -

de Vos MG, Top JL, van Hage WR, Schreiber AT. Transparency of Environmental Computer Models. In Proceedings of the AISB 2013 symposium on enabling Domain experts to use Formalized reasoning (DoForm). Exeter, UK. 2013